When Does a Reasonable Train Route Become Unreasonable?
When Does a Reasonable Train Route Become Unreasonable?

A reader has questioned what counts as a "reasonable" route after experiencing significant delays and cancellations on both legs of a return trip between London and Edinburgh. The query, submitted by email to The Guardian's Notes and Questions column, asks who decides what is reasonable and what is not.

What Happened on the Journey

At Waverley station, a message over the public address system told passengers they could travel by any "reasonable" route. The reader, identified only as Grant, was left wondering what that instruction actually means in practice.

The question touches on a common situation for rail passengers when services are disrupted, and the term "reasonable" is used without clear definition.

Who Decides What Is Reasonable?

The column invites readers to post their answers or send new questions to the provided email address, with a selection of responses published the following Sunday.

The discussion forms part of a long-running series in which readers answer other readers' questions on subjects ranging from trivial flights of fancy to profound scientific and philosophical concepts.