The M&S Cafe Christmas menu for 2026 introduces a Sweet Caramel Apple Toastie (£6), a Pigs Under Blanket Yorkshire pudding wrap (£8.50) and malt ball-themed drinks, alongside returning favourites. Our reviewer sampled the full festive range across two Manchester-area stores and rated each item.
Sweet Caramel Apple Toastie and Yorkshire Pudding Wraps
The Sweet Caramel Apple Toastie layers thick Bramley apple compote with oozing vanilla custard between hefty slices of brioche bread, served with a tub of caramel dip. The reviewer noted it initially tasted more like cream cheese than custard, and found the savoury-toastie expectation made for a strange sensation. Dipping the bread into the sweet caramel dip improved it, though opinions were divided. Rating: 3/5.
The Pigs Under Blanket Yorkshire pudding wrap (£8.50) is new for 2026, building on last year's Yorkie wraps. It contains hefty sausages and bacon layers with port and onion chutney, gravy and a cheesy bechamel sauce. The reviewer called it deeply satisfying, though oozy and messy, and noted it is a huge portion that could easily be shared. Rating: 5/5.
Returning Toasties and Soup
The slow cooked British beef Yorkshire pudding wrap (£8.50) returns with a slightly modified shape and more gravy this year, but the horseradish sauce was found a tad overpowering. The beef was soft with a satisfying crunch from vegetables, but the reviewer's portion was a little burnt. Rating: 3/5.
The Turkey Toastie (£7.50) has been a favourite in recent years, but on this occasion both reviewers found the top half so hard it seemed stale while the bottom was soggy, and the innards less tasty than last year. Rating: 3/5. The French Brie and Cranberry Toastie (£6.95) was a real delight with no burnt bits, featuring an almost garlic bread flavour to the toast and gooey cheese matched with rich cranberry. Rating: 5/5.
The turkey and ham soup (£6) contains chunks of turkey and beechwood ham in a tangy broth. One reviewer's friend hailed it her favourite of the lot, while the reviewer wanted more substance and recalled previous years had a pastry topper. It remains a healthy option. Rating: 4/5.
Cake and Festive Drinks
Rodney the Reindeer is back from last year as a chocolate figure atop a layered cake with rich ganache and a blob of green buttercream. The cakes are made at Oldham's Park Cakes. Rating: 5/5.
New drinks include malt ball hot chocolate and milkshake, both with chocolate squirty cream, and gingerbread lattes (hot or cold), all priced at £4.75. A new caramel apple iced matcha costs £5.50. Ratings: Caramel Apple Iced Matcha 5/5, Malt Ball Hot Chocolate 4/5, Malt Ball Milkshake 5/5, Butterscotch Gingerbread Latte 3/5.
The Verdict
The reviewer concluded that M&S continues to tap into trends effectively, evidenced by daily queues. The new sausage Yorkie is a genius addition, though heavy on calories. A pot of gravy could be added to the turkey toastie, which the reviewer realised afterwards. The turkey soup offers a healthier, lighter choice amid the more decadent treats. The only downside is that the menu is likely to mean even bigger queues over the next five weeks amid the festive shopping frenzy. The M&S Cafe Christmas menu is available now across the UK.