ASDA pulls out of Stockport store plan after appeal win
ASDA pulls out of Stockport store plan after appeal win

ASDA has confirmed it is no longer proceeding with plans for a new store in Stockport, despite a planning inspector granting permission for the development earlier this week.

The decision follows a lengthy dispute over a proposal to demolish a car repair garage and MOT test centre at 22 Marple Road in Offerton and replace it with a new shop, which was expected to be occupied by ASDA Express.

Controversial plans faced strong opposition

Stockport council originally rejected the developer-led plans earlier this year. The proposal drew significant opposition, with a letter of objection signed by 1,800 people and 1,272 individual comments submitted on the council's planning portal. Concerns centred on the potential impact on local independent businesses and the possible loss of jobs.

The council argued that the plans did not demonstrate that the proposed retail use could be properly and safely serviced without harming highway safety and parking. The plans included 13 car parking spaces.

Appeal overrules council decision

Aim Capital Ltd appealed the decision, and planning inspector Katie McDonald overruled the council, granting permission for the development to go ahead. She described the council's concerns about overspill parking as largely speculative, noting she had observed vehicles parked on-street without any apparent impediment to traffic flow.

She stated: "There is no substantive evidence before me that the proposal would lead to an unacceptable increase in highway movements." The council was also criticised for not approaching cases in a consistent manner, with conditions imposed on the applicant described as unreasonable behaviour, resulting in the council having to pay full costs.

Mark Aylward, the planning agent for the appeal on behalf of AIM Capital, said: "We welcome the inspectorate's decision to allow this appeal. We recognise that the application did generate some strong local feeling." He added that the inspector agreed the accompanying evidence was robust and that the scheme was acceptable and should be allowed.

ASDA's withdrawal and local reaction

Despite the developer's success, an ASDA spokesperson said the company is no longer proceeding with its plans for a new store at the site.

Manor councillor Jon Byrne said he was really disappointed and claimed the application had the most amount of objections in Stockport planning history. He said: "Local businesses are the lifeblood of our communities, and the shops around Hempshaw Lane and Marple Road are shining examples of that, supporting our most vulnerable residents day in, day out."

He added: "I'm really disappointed that the council's case was rejected. Planning policy, both local and national, needs to better recognise the special place these local shops hold. I'll be doing everything I can to support our independent traders and I'd urge residents to keep shopping local."