Truck driver denies knowing he hit cyclist in Manchester crash
Truck driver denies knowing he hit cyclist in crash

A trial has heard that a man accused of causing death by careless driving in Manchester city centre was not aware he had struck a teenage cyclist until after the collision, and had to be alerted by members of the public.

Nawaf Al-Ghamdi, 19, was cycling along Great Bridgewater Street on May 24, 2023, when he collided with a flatbed truck and was killed. Jurors at Manchester Crown Court were told on November 17 that the driver, Michael Yates, 58, of Kirkfell Walk in Oldham, denies causing Mr Al-Ghamdi's death.

Collision details

Prosecutor Niamh McGinty told jurors in her opening that the collision took place just before midday. Mr Yates had been driving a flatbed truck eastwards after turning left off Deansgate and was delivering equipment to a building site. Mr Al-Ghamdi was travelling along the same road behind Mr Yates, riding in the cycle lane to the left of the truck.

As they approached the junction with Watson Street, where the lights were red, Mr Yates slowed down while Mr Al-Ghamdi continued in the cycle lane towards the rear of the vehicle. "The lights then changed to green again, so Mr Yates continued through the lights without coming to a complete stop," the prosecutor said. "He then slowed and put his left indicator on and began to turn left, turning into Mr Al-Ghamdi who by this point was to the left of the truck. He fell under the vehicle."

Investigation and evidence

Despite assistance from members of the public and treatment from paramedics, Mr Al-Ghamdi died from his injuries at the scene. Ms McGinty told the court that Mr Yates had failed to keep a sufficient lookout for cyclists and was delayed in indicating his intention to turn left.

Mr Yates was arrested and interviewed that day. "It was only when he was alerted by others that he realised what had happened," Ms McGinty said. "He told police he had stopped and carried out all regular mirror checks but had not seen the cyclist."

Jurors were shown a short CCTV clip of the collision, recorded from around 100 yards away. They were told Mr Al-Ghamdi had not been wearing high-vis clothing at the time.

Former PC Robert Wilson, a collision investigator for 12 years before retiring in 2025, attended the scene at around 1pm on May 24, 2023, examined the vehicle and took a 3D scan of the scene. Photos shown to jurors included an image of Mr Al-Ghamdi's bike caught under the rear wheels of the truck, as well as photographs from the driver's seat showing what could be seen from the truck mirrors, which were said to be fitted and positioned correctly. Officers also photographed Mr Yates' phone, found on the centre console with Google Maps open and a journey engaged.

Defence challenges

Defence barrister Lisa Judge questioned the integrity of the footage, asking whether video does not always capture every millisecond of an incident. PC Wilson agreed that if a camera records frames every 0.5 seconds, there can be a jump where a period is not recorded, and that the jury was considering at what point indicators were activated.

Ms Judge also challenged the value of photos taken from inside the truck, noting that another police officer was stationed at various points along the vehicle and that the photos did not show what was visible regarding the victim's position. She questioned why the truck had not been moved backwards on the closed road to recreate its path. "We could have been accused of trying to manipulate or manufacture something," the officer replied. "We decided not to."

Michael Yates denies a single charge of causing death by careless driving. The trial continues.