A waste management company has been found guilty of corporate manslaughter after a worker was killed by an excavator at a site in Dukinfield, Tameside. John Graveson, 42, died on March 3, 2023, after a Hyundai excavator driven by machine operator Jonathan Horan reversed over him at Aspire House industrial estate.
Mr Graveson, a picker at AMP NW Ltd, now Waste Solutions Mcr Ltd, had gone to work that morning expecting to return home to his partner Shelly and their daughter. He was killed instantly, and his family said the void he leaves behind is "incredibly vast."
Trial at Manchester Crown Court
Mr Horan, 34, of The Crescent, Worsthorne, Burnley, and the company's director Anthony Elston, 48, of Wicket Grove, Clifton, were both cleared of gross negligence manslaughter. However, they were found guilty of failing to discharge general health, safety and welfare duty to an employee. The company also pleaded guilty to the same offence.
The trial heard that Mr Graveson's death was an "accident waiting to happen" and that the company had "no identifiable safe system in place." CCTV footage showed workers and heavy machinery operating in close proximity, with vehicles moving around the site without segregation measures. In one clip, workers kicked a football around as machinery drove past them.
Unsafe working practices
Prosecutors described the environment as "chaotic, unregulated and dangerous." The Crown argued the company failed to carry out an adequate risk assessment, had no traffic management plan, and did not ensure the excavator's 360-degree camera was operational.
Prosecutor Alan Compton KC told the court in September: "The prosecution say this was an entirely avoidable accident. Because of the way the yard was being run by the company and Mr Elston, it was sadly an accident that was waiting to happen."
Detective Chief Inspector David Moores, from GMP's Serious Crime Division, said the investigation uncovered an "alarming pattern" of unsafe working practices. He said: "The risks were obvious, persistent and entirely preventable."
Family's grief
Mr Graveson's partner Shelly said: "As the legal process comes to an end, sadly our grief does not. John was an incredible man whose warmth and love left an indelible mark on everyone lucky enough to know him."
She added: "John should never have gone to work and not turned home to his family, and this will be a devastating reality forever as his daughter reaches many milestones in his absence."
Sentencing will take place on February 4, 2027. DCI Moores said: "While no conviction can undo their loss, we hope this outcome serves as a stark reminder that employers who fail in their duty to protect their workforce will be held accountable."