Asda's own-brand mayonnaise came out on top in a taste test against Hellmann's and five other supermarket versions, scoring a perfect 10/10. The comparison, carried out by Mia O'Hare, Senior Audience Writer for Spare Time, found the Asda option superior in colour, richness and consistency.
How the Test Was Done
Mayonnaise is a staple condiment in UK households, used to enhance sandwiches, serve as a dip for chips, and spread across salads. With both branded and non-branded versions stocked on shelves, most UK supermarkets offer their own. Hellmann's is a popular brand, but supermarket own-brand mayonnaise often comes out cheaper.
The test compared Hellmann's with mayonnaise from Aldi, Lidl, Sainsbury's, Asda, Tesco and Marks and Spencer. The results surprised the tester.
Rankings and Ratings
Tesco's mayonnaise, priced at 86p, came last with a 2/10 rating. The tester felt it was far too vinegary, which overshadowed everything else. Lidl's offering, at 95p, was the whitest of the bunch and carried a sour taste. Despite being pleasantly creamy, it lacked sufficient flavour, earning a 3/10.
Sainsbury's mayo, at 89p, was the thickest in the test and notably pale in colour. It had a pleasing strength and flavour, making it suited for those seeking a thick mayonnaise to top salads. It scored 6/10.
Hellmann's and the Winner
Hellmann's, priced at £2.75 from Tesco, scored 8/10. It was described as wonderfully creamy with a delightful balance between sweetness and tanginess, and an excellent consistency. Aldi's mayonnaise, at 95p, was indistinguishable in flavour from Hellmann's, boasting the same richness and well-balanced taste, also scoring 8/10.
Marks and Spencer took second place with the priciest own-brand offering at £1.20. It tasted notably different from the others, being remarkably light and airy with a delightful tang and smoothness, scoring 9/10. Asda's mayonnaise, at 96p, claimed the top spot, delivering a satisfying tang and a velvety consistency, and comes in considerably cheaper than Hellmann's.
