Residents in a Gloucestershire village say their lives have been "ruined" by a giant metal car workshop that looms over their gardens, blocking sunlight and creating noise that disrupts sleep. The structure, built by business owner Peter Davidson for Shire Cars, has been refused retrospective planning permission by Tewkesbury Borough Council.
Residents describe 'oppressive' building
The 7.1m tall and 33m long metal building, dubbed a "shoebox" by locals, overlooks the back garden of Mark Welsh, 55, who said it has "permanently ruined" his family bungalow. He described living in the gloom as "depressing."
Mr Welsh, a married father-of-two who runs a product and business design company, said: "It's the largest building within a half-mile radius and it's so close you can stand in our garden and reach out and knock on the wall. From the moment the walls went up, we have been shut off and imprisoned in the dark."
He added that the family had to drain their pond because it was covered in algae, cannot get a phone signal in some places, cannot install solar panels, and have to have the heating on more. "And living in gloom is depressing. So now we face another long, dark winter, while Shire Cars continue trading in their giant premises," he said.
Planning objections and noise complaints
Mr Welsh objected to the planning permission along with 36 other people. He said the building ended up around 1.2 times bigger than originally planned. "Architecturally it has ruined everything that ever made our house nice, and now we're fighting to preserve it. It's the architectural volume of it, the bulk. It's completely inappropriate, it's a giant shoebox sat right on the boundary," he explained.
Other neighbours complained that flagpoles and flags erected on the site generated "excessive noise." One resident wrote: "The sound that the flags make is comparable to continuous banging, similar to bins being struck repeatedly, and is particularly disruptive during quieter periods such as at night. This disturbance has affected our sleep, woken our children, and is having a detrimental impact on our health and wellbeing."
Owner faces bankruptcy risk
Mr Davidson, 61, says he was granted full approval to undertake the work and maintains he has done nothing wrong. He applied to redevelop Shire Cars and extend the building in 2022, and spent around £1.5 million on the build.
He said: "The strain on my family and I is phenomenal, I've cashed every pension I have, re-mortgaged our home and sold my cars. If I'm not successful I'll be bankrupt." He added: "The council have made me look like this bloke who just decided out of the blue to build whatever they want, without caring about anyone else. It couldn't be further from the truth. But I'd never have invested my life savings without planning permissions - I'm just an ordinary bloke and I've been left looking like I intentionally flouted the rules."
Mr Davidson said he faced unexpected deviations from the original plan which led to breaches in planning permissions. He added: "But the fundamental thing is that the building is still 99 per cent of the approved plan from 2022. Fundamentally we've not done anything wrong."
Council refuses retrospective permission
Shire Cars submitted a retrospective application for the deviations from the originally approved 2022 plan in November 2025. Last month, Tewkesbury Borough Council's planning department refused permission, declaring the building in breach.
The council said: "Its mass, height and proximity to the shared boundary with the neighbouring dwelling known as Tynings Reach, would appear unduly dominant and overbearing and would result in unacceptable overshadowing, loss of light and harm to outlook from habitable rooms and the outdoor amenity space serving that property."
Shire Cars say they will lodge a further appeal with the Secretary of State should their first appeal be denied. Councillor Sarah Hands, lead member for planning and place making at Tewkesbury Borough Council, said: "Councillors refused the application as they felt the size, height and position of the development would have an unacceptable impact on a neighbouring property, by reducing light and affecting its outlook. The applicant has the right to appeal to the Planning Inspectorate, which would independently review the case."