An estate agent has challenged BestAgent over its use of property marketing material, £8 viewing enquiries and anonymous comments on vendors' homes, prompting fresh questions about the platform's operating model.
Andrew Muskett, manager at David Burr in Woolpit, Suffolk, has raised concerns after discovering his agency's property listings on the platform founded by Charlie Lamdin. The listings included photographs, floorplans and descriptions that Muskett says neither his agency nor its vendors had authorised BestAgent to reproduce. He subsequently tested the platform's viewing enquiry system and questioned its arrangements for removing marketing content and moderating public comments.
"For me, this has become about much more than copyright. It's about agents having control over their marketing material, protecting their vendors' interests and understanding how enquiries generated from their listings are being handled," he said.
BestAgent defends right to display property listings
BestAgent has defended its right to publish factual information about properties being marketed for sale. In a statement shared with the press, the company said: "Basic facts about a property for sale aren't anyone's copyright, and it's in the public interest that they can be shown publicly.
"That includes its address, price, size and status, its location, and public records such as HM Land Registry price paid data, the Energy Performance Certificate (EPC) register, and, exclusively to BestAgent, local land charges data direct from Land Registry servers.
"The law lets agents ask us to remove material that they or their clients own the copyright in (eg photos). It doesn't give a right to remove the listing itself."
The statement distinguishes factual property information from copyright-protected marketing material. However, it does not explain what permissions BestAgent relies upon when initially reproducing agents' photographs, floorplans or property descriptions.
Agent tests BestAgent's £8 viewing enquiry system
Muskett submitted a viewing request through BestAgent for a property marketed by David Burr. He then monitored the process from both the buyer's and selling agent's perspectives. As the agent, he received emails requesting £8 plus VAT to access the enquiry and confirm the appointment. He deliberately declined to pay.
BestAgent initially informed the prospective buyer that the viewing required the agent's acceptance. However, Muskett says he received no subsequent update when the appointment failed to proceed.
"The appointment time simply came and went," he said.
Muskett questioned whether genuine buyers could miss out on viewings when agents decline to purchase enquiries. "How many potential viewings could be lost because an agent hasn't paid for an enquiry, without either party knowing what's happened?" he asked. His test does not establish how frequently enquiries fail to progress.
Anonymous property comments raise concerns
Muskett has also challenged BestAgent's public commenting feature. He identified three David Burr properties featured in Lamdin's LinkedIn posts, including homes in Bradfield St George, Long Thurlow and Great Green. Some comments criticised the properties' layouts, facilities and locations.
Muskett said his agency could not establish whether the contributors had viewed the homes or whether their observations were accurate.
"My particular concern is that neither David Burr nor our vendors have authorised BestAgent to reproduce our marketing content, yet anonymous individuals are being encouraged to publish comments about our clients' homes.
"We have no means of verifying, editing or removing those comments, and I struggle to understand how we're expected to explain that to our vendors."
According to Muskett, BestAgent's correspondence indicates that agents can moderate comments by activating its BackOffice system and granting a licence to their marketing content. "I struggle to understand how that protects the interests of vendors," he said.
BestAgent offers £500 in lead credits
The dispute intensified when Muskett requested the removal of David Burr's marketing material. BestAgent subsequently outlined options for handling the agency's listings. According to Muskett, the platform offered £500 in lead credits if David Burr withdrew its removal request and activated BackOffice. The company also indicated that it could remove copyrighted marketing content while retaining factual property information.
Muskett said agents proceeding with removal would lose access to comment moderation. They could also face a reactivation fee if they subsequently changed their minds.
"Having reproduced our marketing material without our permission, BestAgent is now presenting us with three options for what it is prepared to do with that material, offering £500 in lead credits to withdraw our removal request and warning of reactivation fees if we subsequently change our minds."
He also questioned the platform's licensing arrangements. "If BestAgent believes it already has the necessary rights to reproduce our photographs, floorplans and descriptions, why is it now asking agents to grant it a licence?"
Where does BestAgent obtain its listings?
Muskett wants BestAgent to explain where it obtains property data and what permissions support its use. He has questioned whether the information comes directly or indirectly from Rightmove, other portals or third-party suppliers. However, he acknowledges having no evidence that BestAgent obtains its listings from Rightmove.
"Given the volume of listings on BestAgent, I think it's important to establish whether the information is being obtained from Rightmove, another portal or a third-party supplier," he said.
Muskett also claims that numerous independent agents have discovered their listings on BestAgent without their knowledge. He says he has discussed the situation with senior figures at Connells Group and understands that PFG is examining the matter. EYE has not independently verified those claims.
Further questions concern BestAgent's regulatory obligations and the handling of prospective buyers' personal information. Muskett has not established whether the platform has breached any legal or regulatory requirements.
Agent calls for answers from BestAgent
Muskett believes the dispute raises wider questions about agents' control over their marketing content and the relationship between buyers, sellers and third-party platforms.
"We are instructed by our vendors to market and sell their properties, and we invest considerable time and money in doing so. I don't believe a third-party business should simply be able to reproduce that work, introduce its own commercial arrangements and potentially interfere with the relationship between buyers, sellers and their instructed agents without proper scrutiny."
While BestAgent has publicly defended its right to display factual property information, questions remain about its use of marketing content, paid viewing enquiries and comment moderation. The concerns raised do not, in themselves, establish copyright infringement or a regulatory breach.