Pension savers could face a "loyalty penalty" as retirement funds are gradually diminished through fees, with one analysis showing the potential cost gap between the cheapest and priciest provider reaching more than £60,000 over time, Which? has cautioned.
Which? examines drawdown fees
The consumer organisation examined pension drawdown, a method of withdrawing money from a pension pot while keeping the remainder invested so the fund can potentially keep growing. This enables savers who have reached the point of drawing an income from their pension to decide how much and how frequently they wish to withdraw, while the remaining funds stay invested.
Which? scrutinised the annual charges levied by 18 drawdown providers, examining a variety of different pot sizes. The largest analysed was £750,000. The consumer organisation calculated that, considering the most competitive charges versus the most expensive, over a decade, factoring in annual investment growth of 5%, a drawdown customer could potentially incur £61,877 more in fees with the costliest option compared to the most affordable.
Savers staying with existing providers
Which? also revealed that a survey of more than 1,700 drawdown customers aged 55 and over in September found that when establishing their pension drawdown plan, 50% had stayed with their existing pension provider, rather than exploring the market. The consumer group noted that when considering pension drawdown options, individuals may also need to account for the cost of financial advice, which many providers stipulate at some stage during the process.
Which? highlighted FCA data indicating that around 44 per cent of those accessing pension pots via drawdown in 2025-26 received financial advice. While underlining the considerable value of obtaining such guidance, the organisation also drew attention to the expense involved, which combined with fees could potentially make a "significant" dent in a modest pot.
Cost of financial advice
It referenced figures from VouchedFor, revealing that hiring an independent financial adviser to manage drawdown investments on a £250,000 fund would cost approximately £5,000 upfront, followed by ongoing charges of around £10,000 over the subsequent five years (0.8 per cent, per annum).
Paul Davies, a pensions expert at Which?, said: "Retirees today are under immense pressure to make every pound in their pension count, but blind brand loyalty could quietly cost them tens of thousands of pounds over their retirement.
"Platform fees and hidden charges compound over time, quietly chipping away at your future spending power. It pays to shop around and be deliberate about what you actually need from a platform. Just a few hours spent comparing providers today could preserve a substantial chunk of your nest egg for the years ahead."
Becky O'Connor, head of pensions at PensionBee, said: "Retirees need to make the most of the savings they have built up through working life. Paying attention to the value for money offered by their drawdown plan, including investment performance, management of volatility, technology supporting flexibility and ease of drawdown, fees and customer service, is important.
"But not all drawdown arrangements are the same and it can be very difficult to compare plans from different providers due to different charging structures and services. Asking questions of your provider, doing your own research, seeking guidance from Pension Wise, and speaking to an independent financial adviser are the key ways to help people make good decisions on where to keep retirement savings."
Marc Stewart, head of financial advice distribution at Skipton Building Society, said: "A pension may need to support you for decades, so it's important to shop around and consider whether your pension still offers good value and suits your needs in retirement.
"But fees shouldn't be looked at in isolation. Investment performance, withdrawal levels and changing income needs can all play a part in how long a pot lasts. Savers should be looking at the whole picture, rather than focusing on one number alone. Reviewing your pension regularly and understanding both what you're paying and what you're getting in return can help you make more informed decisions about your retirement."