A prominent engineer has strongly criticised the Victorian government's controversial plan to demolish several public housing towers in Melbourne, labelling the move as short-sighted and damaging to both residents and architectural heritage.
Expert Warns of Irreversible Consequences
The structural engineer, who has worked extensively on Melbourne's high-rise buildings, argues that the proposed demolition of the 1960s-era towers would not only displace vulnerable communities but also erase important examples of post-war urban design.
Community Impact Concerns
"These buildings are structurally sound and with proper maintenance could serve residents for decades to come," the engineer stated. "The human cost of displacing hundreds of low-income families during a housing crisis cannot be overstated."
Heritage Value Overlooked
The condemnation comes as heritage advocates highlight the towers' significance as examples of Brutalist architecture and important markers of Melbourne's social housing history. Critics argue the government's redevelopment plans prioritise developer interests over community needs.
Government Defends Redevelopment Plans
The Victorian government maintains that the ageing towers require replacement to meet modern living standards, promising that all current residents will be rehoused in the new development. However, sceptics question whether the promised one-for-one replacement of social housing units will materialise.
As the public inquiry continues, housing advocates are calling for alternative solutions that preserve both the buildings and the communities they house, suggesting refurbishment rather than demolition could address maintenance issues while keeping residents in place.
