Milburn: Labour must back youth welfare reforms to avoid 'lost generation'
Milburn: Labour must back youth welfare reforms

Alan Milburn, the author of a Government-commissioned report, has said Labour MPs must support sweeping changes to tackle the youth unemployment crisis, even though welfare cuts will mean pain for some young people. The former health secretary wants billions of taxpayers’ money spent on creating opportunities for those aged under 25 to move off benefits and into work, partly offsetting the cost by squeezing welfare payments.

Report calls for action on Neets

Mr Milburn’s report, published on Tuesday, recommends changes across education, industry and social security to address the problem of 16-24 year-olds not in education, employment or training (Neet). The number of Neets topped a million earlier this year for the first time in more than a decade.

The former Labour cabinet minister described reforming welfare as a “litmus test” for the party, acknowledging there would be upfront costs to the taxpayer to create opportunities and support to get people into work and avoid a “lost generation”.

Funding and welfare changes

Mr Milburn will ask Andy Burnham’s Government to provide a £0.5 billion payment in the next financial year as the first stage of his 10-year plan. In total, the plan would involve around £5.8 billion a year of funding by 2036-37, offset by £3.6 billion of welfare savings and £2.4 billion of extra tax revenue from people in work.

Under the plan, under-25s would stop being eligible for the disability benefit personal independence payment (Pip) and the health element of universal credit (UC), with a new “youth allowance” proposed instead.

Political response and concerns

Speaking to Sky News, Mr Milburn said Labour MPs “have to vote for it”, adding: “Labour is what it says on the tin. It’s the party of work. It’s not the party of welfare and of benefits.” He said he had received an “incredibly positive” response at a private meeting with Labour MPs on Monday night because they recognised a “moral imperative” to act, as well as the economic benefits.

Mr Milburn acknowledged that policies introduced since Labour came into office in 2024 had contributed to the Neet problem by making it more expensive to hire younger workers. The Government has pushed up national insurance costs for employers and increased the minimum wage for younger workers at a faster rate than for older employees. He said: “Well, there’s no doubt that that has hit business sentiment. Absolutely, no doubt at all… Employers have come to me and said that that has made it harder.”

Impact and ambitions

Other reported recommendations include gradually cutting national insurance paid by businesses on workers aged under 25, starting in retail and hospitality, as well as a “legal guarantee” of work, training or employment support for young people, with those who refuse potentially losing benefits. Mr Milburn said: “I think, honestly, if you can work a few hours a week rather than working none and doomscrolling in your bedroom, that’s a step forward. In the end, for the vast majority of young people, work beats welfare every single time.”

Mr Milburn has previously warned the Neet figure could rise from one in eight to one in six by 2031 without action, representing 1.25 million young people. The report estimates the crisis is costing the UK around £125 billion a year, including losses in taxes alongside higher health and welfare spending. It sets out a national ambition to reduce the Neet rate by more than half from 13% to around 5% by 2036, which would make the UK one of Europe’s best performers on youth participation. The UK rate has never been lower than 9.7% since data began in 2001.

The reforms, including early years and schools, apprenticeships and health and welfare support, would result in 600,000 more young people in education, employment or training each year – around 440,000 of whom would be in sustained work – by 2036, according to modelling for the report. A new youth opportunity service across all of England by 2029 would aim to ensure employment, careers, health and practical support are available, with a personalised participation plan and a named adviser. An opportunity guarantee would offer a route into education, training or work, while a support guarantee would provide any health, employment and practical help needed.

The plan also aims to double the number of young people completing an apprenticeship over the decade, hoping this path will rival university as a mainstream route for school leavers, while faster access to mental health support for Neet young people without waiting for a diagnosis is recommended. Statistics out earlier this month showed just under half (45.3%) of Neets were classed as disabled in the year to March, a proportion which has more than doubled in just over a decade.

Charities have voiced concern at the idea of cutting benefit support aimed at covering the extra costs of living with a disability. Harriet Edwards from disability charity Sense said: “We share Alan Milburn’s ambition to break down the barriers that prevent young disabled people who want to work from doing so.” She added: “We urge the Government to provide urgent reassurance that no young disabled person with complex needs will be left worse off.”

Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said: “We don’t need costly government schemes to fix Labour’s own mistakes. We need to stop making it so expensive and risky to hire young people. But Labour MPs who whacked business with the jobs tax, brought in the Employment Rights Act, and raised the minimum age for young people so high that business stopped hiring them, won’t vote for common sense. So sadly we won’t see any welfare savings under Andy Burnham, just more bluster and hot air.”