‘Truly vile’: the UK’s 25 best (and worst) novelty hot cross buns – tested!
‘Truly vile’: the UK’s 25 best (and worst) novelty hot cross buns – tested!

Hot cross buns, the Easter treat traditionally eaten on Good Friday, now appear in shops as early as January. While purists may turn up their noses at non-traditional varieties, supermarkets are offering an ever-growing range of novelty flavours, from red velvet to tiramisu. To see if these modern twists are worth the hype, we tested 25 non-traditional buns, toasted and buttered, with a classic M&S luxury fruited bun as a control.

Among the chocolate-based offerings, the Waitrose No 1 Belgian chocolate buns (£2 for two) scored 5/10. They had a sophisticated dark-chocolate flavour but tasted more like a toasted chocolate muffin than a hot cross bun. The Tesco Finest triple chocolate buns (£2 for four) were criticised for being too sweet and creating a sticky mess in the toaster, earning 4/10. Waitrose milk chocolate & fudge buns (£2 for four) fared better at 7/10, with a properly chocolatey taste and delicate sweetness, though the fudge was undetectable.

At the lower end, Iceland Luxury extremely chocolatey buns (£1.80 for four) were described as “disgusting”, dry and with a synthetic cocoa flavour, scoring just 2/10. Lidl Deluxe triple chocolate buns (£1.49 for four) were similar to Tesco’s in stickiness and sweetness but gained an extra point for value, finishing at 5/10. The M&S red velvet filled buns (£3.50 for four) were deemed style over substance, seemingly designed for social media appeal rather than taste.

Becca Stock, a food reviewer on TikTok and Instagram, notes that novelty buns should be viewed as a separate product from traditional ones. She observes that retailers are increasingly creating wackier flavours to generate online buzz, with M&S even labelling some items as “as seen on social”. Charles Banks of the food trends agency thefoodpeople adds that offering both traditional and novelty options increases the “weight of purchase” for shoppers, and any purist outrage only creates free publicity.