Supermarket own-brand tomato soups have outperformed household names like Heinz and Baxters in a blind taste test carried out by Which?, with Tesco and Sainsbury's tins costing 59p each sharing the top spot.
The consumer champion assembled a panel of 77 soup enthusiasts to taste 12 tinned tomato soups. Each soup was assessed on overall flavour, texture, appearance, aroma, sweetness, tanginess, thickness and creaminess. The tasting was conducted blind, meaning tasters were not told whether they were sampling Heinz, Baxters or a cheaper supermarket option, and they were prohibited from discussing their views to avoid influencing fellow tasters.
Top-Rated Tins
Tesco Cream of Tomato Soup and Sainsbury's Cream of Tomato Soup both scored 78%, tying for the highest rating. Which? said tasters found Tesco's soup "excelled on every measure, with just the right strength of flavour and tang for the majority of tasters," adding that "unlike some lower-scoring soups, there was no compromising on texture, with top marks for thickness and creaminess."
Sainsbury's soup also impressed the panel. Which? said: "Most tasters found the balance of tanginess and sweetness just right. It also won over tasters on appearance and texture, with three quarters rating it the perfect creaminess. It also outstanding value at just 59p a tin."
Branded Soups Fall Short
Heinz Cream of Tomato Soup finished towards the bottom of the rankings with a score of 68%. Which? said "more than a third thought the flavour was too weak and not sweet enough, while 62% said it wasn't creamy enough." The 400g tin costs £1.70, equivalent to 43p per 100g.
Baxters Cream of Tomato Soup was the most expensive tin in the test at £2.05 for 400g (51p per 100g) and scored just 58%, the lowest overall. Most tasters found the flavour too weak and the texture not thick enough.
Mid-Range Performers
Crosse & Blackwell Cream of Tomato Soup was the best-rated brand on test with 76%, though at £1.25 for 400g (31p per 100g) it still costs around double the price of most supermarket own labels. Asda Cream of Tomato Soup came third overall with 77% and was given "Best Buy" status, rated among the best for appearance, aroma, flavour and texture.
Morrisons Cream of Tomato Soup scored 72%, called "a decent option" by tasters, while Marks & Spencer and Co-op both scored 73%. Aldi Bramwells Cream of Tomato Soup scored 71%, just ahead of Lidl Newgate Cream of Tomato Soup at 70%. Waitrose Essential Cream of Tomato Soup was the lowest-scoring own-label soup at 66%, with Which? saying "it lost marks for flavour, and around half thought it wasn't thick or creamy enough".
For shoppers, choosing a supermarket own brand over a premium label offers significant savings, with the winning tins costing a fraction of the price of the market leader Heinz.