Marks & Spencer Gold Instant Coffee and Waitrose Gold Roast have been named the best instant coffees in the UK, each scoring 70% in a blind taste test carried out by Which?. The two supermarket own-brand blends outperformed established names including Nescafé Gold Blend, Kenco Gold Indulgence and Douwe Egberts Pure Gold.
How the tasting worked
Which?, described as a leading UK consumer champion, assembled a panel of 68 coffee enthusiasts to taste-test 12 instant gold-roast style coffees. Every coffee was rated on its appearance, flavour, mouthfeel and aroma. The evaluation was conducted as a blind taste test, meaning participants had no idea whether they were sampling Nescafé, Kenco or a budget supermarket blend. Tasters were equally prohibited from sharing their views with one another to avoid any outside influence on their judgements.
The results in full
- Lidl Bellarom Gold - 61%: This emerged as the "least-enjoyed coffee of all", with only just over a third of tasters appreciating the flavour. Slightly fewer than half approved of the bitterness levels. £2.65 for 200g.
- Ocado Gold Roast - 64%: Which? noted that half of the panel "felt this coffee had the right bitterness, but fewer were enamoured with its flavour". £3 for 200g.
- Asda Gold Roast - 64%: Which? described this as a "cheap blend that looked and smelled good, but less than half were fans of the flavour or bitterness". £2.65 for 200g.
- Sainsbury's Gold Roast - 65%: Fewer than half of the Which? panel were satisfied with its flavour, though bitterness levels received greater approval. £2.85 for 200g.
- Morrisons Gold Roast - 65%: The Which? tasters said this one was "not bad, and a cheap option, but dropped marks for flavour, with a third finding it too weak". £2.65 for 200g.
- Co-op Fairtrade Gold Roast - 67%: The coffee tasters said this one was "a reasonably well-liked brew with good ethical credentials" but added that "about half would have preferred a stronger coffee flavour". £3.55 for 200g.
- Kenco Gold Indulgence - 68%: "While it wasn't the most favoured, Kenco's coffee was still well received by our tasters," said Which? "With praise for its appearance, aroma and flavour. A half found the coffee flavour just right, although a touch stronger would have suited a third of our tasters. More than half found its bitterness suited them. It's another pricey coffee, so it's worth keeping an eye out for regular offers." £8.35 for 195g.
- Aldi Barissimo Gold Roast Freeze Dried Coffee - 68%: "It's not quite up there with the top scorers, but this coffee from Aldi was enjoyed for its looks, aroma and flavour," said Which? "Bitterness levels were approved by nearly two-thirds, and flavour by just shy of half of our tasters. A little stronger coffee flavour would've boosted its popularity still more. Aldi's coffee is much cheaper than all the other high-scoring coffees, so it wins our Great Value award." £2.65 for 200g.
- Nescafé Gold Blend - 69%: "The iconic coffee brand was enjoyed by our tasters, missing out on being a Best Buy by just a single percentage point," said Which? "Generally, tasters approved of its looks, aroma and flavour. A little over half said its bitterness was just right, although the remainder were split as to whether it should be a little more or less bitter. Approaching half were happy with the Nescafé flavour, but a third wanted a stronger coffee hit." £8.35 for 190g.
- Douwe Egberts Pure Gold - 69%: "Its looks, aroma and flavour were all rated highly," said Which? "Just shy of half said the coffee's strength was just right, while nearly two-thirds praised its bitter kick. Price-wise, it's up there with the more costly options, but if it's your go-to brand, keep an eye out for some supermarkets offering it more cheaply than others." £8 for 190g.
- Waitrose Gold Roast - 70%: Sharing the top spot, this blend impressed across the board. Which? said "it did well across the board, making a favourable first impression for its appearance and aroma, which was confirmed with a decent flavour". It added: "Well over half of our tasters found the coffee's strength spot on, and nearly two-thirds enjoyed the bitter tang. This Waitrose coffee isn't cheap, but it's a crowd pleaser." £3.70 for 100g.
- M&S Gold Instant Coffee - 70%: Sharing top spot with Waitrose was M&S Gold Instant Coffee. Which? said "it scored well for flavour, aroma and appearance". It added: "Nearly two-thirds were happy with the strength of flavour, while close to three-quarters approved of the bitterness levels. It won't be a surprise to learn that M&S's coffee isn't one of the cheaper options, but it does well ethically, being one of just two coffees on test with the Fairtrade logo." £7.25 for 200g.
Savings and health notes
With premium labels costing up to £8.35 for a 190g jar, switching to supermarket own-label alternatives could result in substantial savings. For millions of Britons, messing around with coffee beans or ground coffee, not to mention machines, filters or an aeropress, simply isn't worth the hassle, expense or time investment, and they regard instant coffee as a more convenient and economical option.
On the health front, coffee offers a whole host of benefits. It can boost the diversity of your gut microbiome, and a study by Zoe, the science and nutrition firm co-founded by Professor Tim Spector, revealed that coffee drinkers tended to have greater diversity in their microbiomes. It also contains polyphenols, the beneficial plant-derived chemicals that are known to promote good health. Research also suggests it may lower your risk of cancer, slow cognitive decline, reduce your chances of developing Alzheimer's disease and offer protection against type 2 diabetes. That said, further research is required before all of these potential benefits can be confirmed with certainty.