A recent taste test comparing own-brand baked beans from seven major supermarkets has revealed a surprising winner. The Co-op's offering took the top spot, outperforming budget-friendly rivals Aldi and Lidl as well as market leader Tesco.
The Taste Test Methodology
The reviewer, a regular consumer of baked beans who typically seasons them with paprika, salt, pepper, cumin, and sometimes soy or Worcestershire sauce, decided to sample the beans plain to assess their natural flavour. Each tin was cooked according to package instructions and evaluated on sweetness, consistency, and overall flavour. Scores were given out of 5 for the first two categories and out of 10 for overall flavour, resulting in a final score out of 20.
7. Aldi (40p) - 7.5/20
Aldi's baked beans were deemed the blandest of the bunch. The sauce was described as watery, even after cooking for the recommended time. The reviewer noted a lack of richness and was tempted to add spices to improve the flavour.
6. M&S (55p) - 9.5/20
Marks & Spencer's beans contain no added sugar, which was evident in the taste. While the consistency was acceptable and the sauce was nicely textured, the overall flavour lacked richness and sweetness. These beans may appeal to those who prefer to season their own or seek a lower-sugar option.
5. Sainsbury's (30p) - 10/20
The cheapest option at 30p, Sainsbury's beans suffered from a watery texture with too much sauce. The flavour was weak and needed more sweetness and richness. However, with added seasoning, they could serve as an economical lunch choice.
4. Waitrose (55p) - 15.5/20
Waitrose offered decent flavour and a good consistency with a balanced bean-to-sauce ratio. However, the flavour was not particularly strong, and the reviewer felt the need to season them. Still, they were a respectable option in the test.
3. Lidl (40p) - 16.5/20
Lidl's baked beans impressed with perfect consistency, appealing colour, and an excellent bean-to-sauce ratio. They were sweet, though slightly less sweetness would have been ideal. For 40p, they represent a solid budget choice.
2. Tesco (42p) - 17.5/20
Tesco's beans scored high on sweetness without being overpowering, with a rich flavour and pleasant aroma. The only downside was the consistency, which required a slightly longer cooking time. Nonetheless, they offer great value for under 50p.
1. Co-op (47p) - 18/20
The Co-op's own-brand baked beans took the top spot, surprising the reviewer. The darker colour hinted at a rich flavour, which delivered instantly. The sauce was the strongest-tasting among all samples, with a perfect balance of sweetness and richness. The consistency was excellent, earning a score of 4/5 for consistency, 5/5 for sweetness, and 9/10 for overall flavour.
In conclusion, while many supermarket baked beans are serviceable, the Co-op's offering stands out for its robust taste and satisfying texture, making it the clear winner of this taste test.
