A 59p supermarket own-brand tomato soup has been crowned the best in the UK, outperforming household names such as Heinz and Baxters in a blind taste test conducted by Which?.
The consumer champion gathered a panel of 77 soup tasters to sample 12 tinned tomato soups, evaluating each on flavour, texture, appearance, aroma, sweetness, tanginess, thickness and creaminess. The test was blind, meaning tasters were not told whether they were sampling Heinz, Baxters or a budget-friendly supermarket option, and they were forbidden from discussing their opinions to prevent influencing other tasters.
The Winning Soups
Tesco Cream of Tomato Soup and Sainsbury's Cream of Tomato Soup tied for the top spot, each scoring 78%. Both are priced at 59p for a 400g tin (15p per 100g).
Tesco's soup was noted for excelling on every measure, with testers praising the strength of flavour and tang, as well as top marks for thickness and creaminess. Sainsbury's won over tasters with a balance of tanginess and sweetness, with three quarters rating it the perfect creaminess, and was described as outstanding value at just 59p a tin.
Branded Soups Fall Behind
Asda Cream of Tomato Soup secured third place with 77% and was awarded "Best Buy" status, ranking among the finest for appearance, aroma, flavour and texture. Crosse and Blackwell Cream of Tomato Soup was the highest-rated branded soup at 76%, though it costs £1.25 for 400g (31p per 100g), roughly twice as much as most supermarket own-label alternatives.
Heinz Cream of Tomato Soup placed towards the lower end of the rankings with 68%, with more than a third of tasters finding the flavour too weak and not sweet enough, while 62% said it wasn't creamy enough. Baxters Cream of Tomato Soup, the most costly soup in the test at £2.05 for 400g (51p per 100g), recorded the lowest score overall at 58%, with tasters deeming the flavour excessively weak and the texture lacking sufficient thickness.
Other Results
Waitrose Essential Cream of Tomato Soup scored 66%, the lowest-scoring own-label soup, losing marks for flavour with around half finding it not thick or creamy enough. Lidl Newgate Cream of Tomato Soup scored 70%, with tasters saying it "looked the part" but the flavour and texture fell slightly short. Aldi Bramwells Cream of Tomato Soup scored 71%, impressing on appearance but lacking creaminess for more than half of tasters.
Morrisons Cream of Tomato Soup scored 72%, called "a decent option" with high scores on colour and sweetness, though just over a third wanted a stronger tomato flavour and more tanginess. Marks and Spencer Cream of Tomato Soup and Co-op Classic Cream of Tomato Soup both scored 73%, with M&S praised for thickness and creaminess and Co-op described as "a solid contender with good creaminess and well-balanced flavours".