The Scottish Football Association faces a critical decision following Steve Clarke's resignation as national team manager. Clarke, who led Scotland to three major tournaments despite a limited player pool, stepped down after a disappointing World Cup campaign. The SFA now must find a successor, and according to Ewan Murray, the solution lies outside Scotland's borders.
Clarke's Legacy and the SFA's Missteps
Clarke ended Scotland's long wait for major tournament appearances, qualifying for the Euros and World Cup three times. However, his tenure ended amid criticism after Scotland finished as the 11th-ranked third-placed team out of 12 at the World Cup. The SFA's decision to offer Clarke a four-year contract before the tournament now seems misguided. Murray notes that Clarke's resignation spares both parties an acrimonious split but leaves the SFA in a quandary.
Clarke, 62, has admitted he timed his move from assistant to manager when he was financially secure enough to fail. His post-match media duties in Miami suggested a man ready for a more peaceful life. While criticism of Clarke has been personal and over the top, his departure was inevitable after Scotland's timid exit.
The Need for a Non-Scottish Manager
Murray argues that the Scotland job is no longer for a Scot. The domestic coaching pool is shallow: only two Scottish managers – David Moyes and Alex Neil – work in England's top two leagues. Derek McInnes and Moyes are unattainable due to club commitments. Among Scottish Premiership managers, only John McGlynn of Falkirk is credible, but his ability to command respect from stars like Scott McTominay or John McGinn is questionable. Steven Naismith, Clarke's assistant, is culpable for the World Cup failure, and Paul Lambert has not managed since 2021.
The SFA must look abroad, as other nations have. England have a German manager, Brazil employ Italian Carlo Ancelotti, and Scottish clubs like Hearts and Motherwell have benefited from foreign coaches. A fresh perspective could overhaul a failing national football model.
Timeline and Challenges Ahead
Clarke's replacement must be in place before Scotland's Nations League campaign in September, followed by Euro 2028 qualifying, where Scotland will have an easier path as a host nation. The SFA must raise its game, moving away from a cosy, parochial culture. The appointment of Craig Mulholland as chief football officer has not instilled confidence.
Murray concludes that small-mindedness has harmed Scottish football for decades. By ignoring borders, the SFA can find a manager who can raise expectations and lead Scotland to future success.
