Manchester United are facing a goalkeeping crisis ahead of Thursday's Europa League quarter-final second leg against Lyon, with head coach Ruben Amorim yet to decide between Andre Onana and Altay Bayindir.
Onana was dropped after a couple of mistakes in the first leg draw, making way for Bayindir's Premier League debut against Newcastle. However, the Turkish goalkeeper made an error leading to a goal in a 4-1 defeat at St James' Park, casting further doubt on the position.
Tom Heaton, the third-choice keeper, has not played competitively since August, ruling him out of contention. Our writers are split: some argue Onana remains the best option despite his errors, while others believe Bayindir should be given a run to send a message that underperforming players can be dropped.
Amorim faces a catch-22: reinstalling Onana could breed complacency, while persisting with Bayindir risks further instability. The decision will also signal the manager's stance on accountability within the squad.
