The Oscars in memoriam segment, a tradition since 1994, once again sparked controversy this year as several notable figures were omitted. Among those left out were Brigitte Bardot, James Van Der Beek, Malcolm-Jamal Warner, and Bollywood star Dharmendra, prompting social media outcry.
The selection process, overseen by a committee, involves whittling a longlist of hundreds down to around 30 names. Former Academy executive director Bruce Davis described it as 'agonising', noting that familiar public figures are inevitably dropped. This year's segment included a standalone tribute to Rob Reiner and Michele Singer Reiner, with appearances from Billy Crystal and stars from Reiner's films.
Bardot's omission was particularly notable but complicated by her controversial later life, including far-right involvement and convictions for inciting racial hatred. Similar speculation surrounded the exclusion of Alain Delon last year, with Variety's Peter Debruge citing his 'bad boy behaviour'. Personal conduct is reportedly a factor in committee decisions.
Space constraints also play a role, as the segment must honour not just actors but also directors, casting directors, and other behind-the-scenes figures. Giorgio Armani was included this year for his film costume design. Some omissions, like Van Der Beek and Warner, may reflect their primary fame in television rather than cinema, as Grey's Anatomy creator Shonda Rhimes noted: 'He's not a movie star.'
Critics argue that the process can feel arbitrary, recalling past snubs like Farrah Fawcett in 2010. Despite the outcry, the Academy maintains that the in memoriam segment is a painstaking effort to balance recognition with limited time.
