South Lanarkshire Council is set to raise concerns over Scottish Government proposals that could see reforms to local government. Councillors will consider the council’s response to the proposed public service reforms at a meeting tomorrow (November 4).
Proposals to Replace Current Structure
The Scottish Government’s proposals could see the creation of between six and 10 Regional Authorities, alongside around 120 to 160 Community Authorities, replacing the current local government structure.
Under the suggested model, Regional Authorities could take responsibility for strategic services including education, housing, transport, waste management and economic development, while Community Authorities would focus on more local matters such as planning applications, licensing greenspace and town centre regeneration.
Concerns Over Evidence and Costs
However, South Lanarkshire Council has questioned whether there is sufficient evidence to demonstrate that changing the structure of local government would lead to better services or improved outcomes for residents.
The report highlights concerns that major organisational changes could bring significant transition costs and disruption, potentially diverting resources away from frontline services. It states: “Structural reform cannot, in itself, replace adequate and sustainable resources and no evidence has yet been presented that the proposed model would improve performance after transition costs, organisational disruption and workforce impacts have been taken into account.”
The council also points to the financial pressures already facing local government, highlighting COSLA’s estimate that councils across Scotland face an annual funding gap of more than £500 million.
Alternative Approach Proposed
Rather than replacing existing councils, South Lanarkshire is proposing the greater regional collaboration could be developed through the Glasgow City Region. This could see areas such as economic development, transport and strategic planning considered at a regional level, while councils retain responsibility for delivering local services.
The report makes clear that South Lanarkshire would not support a Regional Authority taking over existing council services including education, social work and roads. It also raises questions about proposals to give schools greater independence from local authorities, warning that changes could create fragmentation and uncertainty around accountability.
The council argues that local decision-making and community involvement should remain central to public services, pointing to its existing neighbourhood plans and Community Partnerships as examples of work already taking place.
Councillors are being asked to note the report and consider approving the proposed response for submission to the Scottish Government. No immediate changes to council services, staffing structures or employment arrangements are being proposed as part of tomorrow’s meeting. The wider public service reform proposals remain under consideration, with the council expected to continue engaging with the Scottish Government as discussions progress.
