Hackney mulls free rent repayment help for tenants
Hackney mulls free rent repayment help for tenants

Hackney Council could offer free support to help tenants recover rent from rogue landlords under proposals due to be debated next week. Green councillors want the authority to establish a service assisting renters with applications for rent repayment orders (RROs), which can force landlords to repay tenants if housing laws have been breached.

Official figures reveal the Town Hall is still owed almost £500,000 in unpaid landlord fines. The motion calls on the borough's Green Mayor, Zoë Garbett, and her cabinet to bring forward proposals for how the council can establish a free service to help private tenants apply to reclaim rent if their landlord breaches renting rules.

Council's Stated Position

“Hackney should be a beacon for private renters, using the Renters’ Rights Act to the full,” the motion states, adding that the council should take the formal position that “a fine on a rogue landlord is finished only when the renter has been paid back”.

Mayor Garbett told the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) she “wholeheartedly” supported the idea. “This motion provides renters with systematic support, using council resources to help them get justice,” she said.

Enforcement Routes Under New Act

Under the Renters’ Rights Act 2025, which took effect in England on May 1, 2026, councils have a legal duty to enforce new private renting rules. Older legislation sets out several enforcement routes for landlords who breach housing law. A first-tier property tribunal commonly imposes an RRO if a landlord lets an unlicensed home, ignores improvement notices, or harasses occupiers. Criminal courts can issue unlimited fines for serious offences like harassment or illegal evictions.

Local authorities can impose civil penalties of up to £40,000 on offending landlords as an alternative to prosecution, and keep the proceeds. Once the civil penalty becomes final, if an affected tenant has also applied for an RRO, the tribunal must award the maximum amount (up to 24 months).

Fines and Collections

In May 2026 — less than a week before the Greens won Hackney’s local elections — the former Labour administration rolled out an expanded property licensing scheme, charging landlords £925 for single-let homes, and £1,400 for HMOs. Official reports state that Hackney has collected £160,390 in civil penalty fines since 2021, though this contradicts figures provided by officers.

The council says it issued 83 civil penalty notices (CPNs) to offending landlords between 2021 and 2025, amounting to £643,157 in fines. During this five-year period, the council collected just over a fifth (£129,890) of what it was owed. Since the start of 2026, Hackney has collected £24,000, bringing the total amount recouped to £153,890.

Speaking to the LDRS, the motion’s author, Cllr George Sheldon Grün (Green, Clissold), said he was “genuinely inspired” by the Labour Housing Secretary, Angela Rayner, for bringing in the 2025 Act. He said: “Right now, you’re more likely to be sanctioned as a benefits claimant than if you’re a landlord harassing tenants. If we oppose lawbreaking and fraud, then residents expect us to uphold the law for everyone, without fear or favour.”

Proposed Service and Costs

If the motion’s proposals are adopted, with every final notice or conviction the council would inform the tenants, whether current or former. Council staff may help tenants apply for an RRO, including by giving advice or managing their case, free of charge. Cllr Sheldon Grün said the service would eventually pay for itself because it would be funded by fines on non-compliant landlords, alongside money from RROs.

Although tribunal-ordered rent repayments typically go to tenants, if rent has been paid for with welfare, either partially or in full, a local housing authority can apply for an RRO. A property tribunal can then order the landlord to pay back the benefit element to the council, but only if the authority is an applicant. Hackney Council has only applied for an RRO once — in 2021, where a claimant partially paid rent with benefits and the council claimed “just over” £3,000, according to reports.

Senior housing officers argued that it would cost the council more to recover these benefit-paid rent payments to law-breaking landlords than it could expect to recoup. The council’s finance director further warned that local authorities can only keep Housing Benefit repayments, arguing that statutory provisions mean Universal Credit clawbacks must be remitted to the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP). This is at odds with statutory guidance published in November 2025, which states that local authorities can keep any money received through RROs as long as it is used for private rental sector enforcement.

However, officers said they would be “more than happy” to develop the service, which is estimated to cost the council at least £542,000 a year. Another option could be to commission a non-profit group such as Justice For Tenants to provide the support, they added. The motion will be debated at Hackney’s next Full Council meeting on Wednesday (November 25).