Newcastle's sexual health service has been praised by health bosses almost a year after a highly critical report by the healthcare watchdog. The service is now run by the NHS after private firm S4H agreed a mutual termination of its contract last year.
The termination followed serious concerns raised by senior Newcastle City Council officials, which led to inspections by independent experts and the Care Quality Commission (CQC). The CQC issued a damning report rating the service as inadequate and revealed breaches of legal regulations in relation to safeguarding, staffing, the safety of premises and equipment, and how the service is managed.
NHS takeover and improved performance
Since March this year, the Ravensworth Terrace clinic has been run by the Sunderland and South Tyneside NHS Foundation Trust (STSFT). The number of appointments delivered has risen sharply and testing for sexually transmitted infections has also increased.
Speaking at Thursday's meeting of the city council's health scrutiny committee, public health consultant Melissa Brown praised the staff at the new service. She said: "Everything has improved significantly since the NHS has taken over. They're doing a fantastic job with lots of compliments from patients and residents, with lots of overall improvement."
Evidence gathering and contract termination
Director of public health in Newcastle Alice Wiseman said it took time to gather the necessary evidence to terminate the contract. She said: "The service started in 2023. When I joined in 2024 there was already anecdotal concerns raised with me."
"Staff have worked incredibly hard - it was about the wider provision of service. I requested CQC went into the service and raised concerns. Throughout the course of the next few months, we continued to go in and visit the service in a much more robust way. We can't go in with an assumption - we have to go in with really clear evidence."
"It takes time to build up that evidence. We have to go through that process - we can't just withdraw a contract, you have to have the evidence. We contacted CQC again in March 2025 and said we were very concerned. They agreed to do an inspection but couldn't give us a timescale."
"I didn't want to wait any longer so we commissioned our own review. We worked really hard. We took action before CQC and CQC said they came in because the council raised concerns and asked them to come in. It is a far better service than we ever had before with previous providers."
Political reaction
The Green Party's Coun Gareth Jones commented: "I was happy to hear when the contract was changed. This was before I was elected, but I'm quite interested in this area and I had heard not great things about the previous service."