Doctor: Is Paying More for Max Strength Medicine Worth It?
Doctor: Is Max Strength Medicine Worth the Extra Cost?

Paying more for "max strength" and branded flu remedies and painkillers is rarely worth it, according to a pharmacist and a GP, who say cheaper supermarket versions contain the same active ingredients. Branded medicines often cost five times as much as supermarket own brands.

For example, Tesco is currently selling a 16-tablet box of Nurofen for £1.90 while selling a box of unbranded ibuprofen of the same strength for 35p. For Nurofen Express, the price increases to £4, with the quantity of ibuprofen increasing from 200mg to 256mg.

As another example, Tesco is selling a box of 10 sachets of Lemsip Max Cold and Flu Sachets for £6.70, while selling 10 sachets of Tesco Health Max Strength Cold & Flu Relief Powder for £3. The max strength Lemsip is also £1.80 more expensive than its non-max strength version. It is also selling 16 tablets of Panadol for £2.15, Panadol Extra for £3.75 and own-brand paracetamol for 35p. All contain the same amount of the active ingredient paracetamol (500mg), but the Panadol Extra also contains caffeine.

What makes a medicine max strength?

There may be more of a certain active ingredient in max strength products, though it is rare for a paracetamol tablet in the UK to contain more than 500mg, though a dose can be two tablets. For example, a Lemsip sachet contains 650mg of paracetamol and 10mg of phenylephrine hydrochloride whereas Lemsip Max contains 1000mg of paracetamol and 12.2mg of phenylephrine hydrochloride.

Max strength tablets also sometimes contain caffeine, which might help the body's absorption of paracetamol. The British Heart Foundation said a recent medical review found that caffeine had "a small but significant effect, amounting to an additional 5-10% of patients achieving a good level of pain relief".

Are they worth the money?

Prof Jayne Lawrence, head of the pharmacy division at the University of Manchester, told the BBC: "The big brands have been around for a while, they've been tested, and there are adverts on the TV saying they're really good. But in reality, there's very little difference. Personally, I'd always go for the cheaper ones — and they've also been tested."

Asked on BBC Radio 4 whether it is worth upgrading to the "max" versions, Prof Lawrence said: "It depends what you're looking for. You need to always read the label, unfortunately, to see what you're getting. In a lot of cases the max strength has got caffeine added in and there is some evidence that caffeine can help the way some analgesics interact. The analgesic is often paracetamol in these medicines. There is potentially some benefit in having the max strength with the caffeine but you have to remember you can also buy a cheaper version of paracetamol and caffeine anyway that doesn't contain the decongestants."

Asked whether people could just take the paracetamol with a cup of coffee instead, Prof Lawrence said: "Yes you could. The caffeine that is in the max is about what you'd get from a normal coffee." Asked what she did when she had a cold, she said: "You can't stop a cold, you can't make it shorter, you can't make it go away, the best you can do is treat the symptoms. So if you have a headache or a sore throat a paracetamol would be really good. If you've got a cough, honey and lemon is really good because it helps soothe the throat. It's really a personal choice if you want to go and buy a branded medicine. Paracetamol is actually very good for colds and if you want to upgrade it to the max strength you can have the caffeine as well."

Branded and supermarket paracetamol 'work exactly the same'

Doctor Mandakini Prabhakar went further. The Cambridge and Hertfordshire-based GP who posts online as Dr Mandy said: "Most big name shelf remedies are either over-priced paracetamol, boiled sweets or ingredients your gut destroys before they even get to work. Most winter bugs just need time, fluids and rest. Skip past the fancy packaging, stick to proven basics."

She added: "You don't need fancy paracetamol or ibuprofen. Exactly the same ingredients as generic supermarket versions but will cost you at least five times more. Instead pick up generic own brands from your supermarket or pharmacy. Work identically to heavily advertised brands and for a fraction of the cost."

She said the decongestant phenylephrine, which is in Lemsip, was "broken down by your gut before it can do any decongesting". The US Food and Drug Administration said in 2024 it was proposing to remove phenylephrine as an active ingredient that can be used in over-the-counter medication for the temporary relief of nasal congestion after a review "determined that oral phenylephrine is not effective for this use".

A spokesperson for Reckitt said: "Our brands have been trusted by consumers for decades to help relieve the symptoms associated with colds and flu. It contains established active ingredients that are approved by medicines regulators, and are combined and formulated to address multiple symptoms, including pain and fever, sore throat, nasal congestion and chesty coughs in a single product. Effective self-care treatments play an important role in enabling those with minor, or manageable illness to look after themselves with confidence at home, leaving critical hospital/NHS resources for those with the highest need and most severe illness. As with all medicines, consumers should always read the label and follow the directions for use."