SNP ministers knew of NHS Grampian deaths warnings years ago
SNP ministers knew of NHS Grampian deaths warnings years ago

Emails passed to the Sunday Mail show that an SNP minister and a top advisor attended crunch talks about whistleblower reports of avoidable deaths at NHS Grampian over four years ago. The meeting took place in October 2022, and those present included former Health Secretary and First Minister Humza Yousaf and then-Chief Medical Officer Gregor Smith. Dr Mohammed Habib's concerns were discussed “in detail” at the meeting.

The government was finally forced to order an independent review on the scandal after a document leaked by Habib showed 19 avoidable deaths at the health board. However, the surgeon's lawyer has warned of an “industrial scale cover up” and demanded John Swinney explain how he could have been unaware of the surgeon's repeated warnings.

Emails reveal government awareness

Emails reveal government officials were aware of Dr Habib's desperate request to SNP ministers for a public inquiry in June 2023, but decided to keep the response “very high level” and “basically just saying we are aware of the issue”. Another email from July 19, 2023, shows NHS Grampian Medical Director Nick Fluck confirming Yousaf and Smith attended the October 2022 meeting at which the damning report into avoidable deaths compiled by Professor Wigmore was “shared and discussed”.

Habib is a consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, which was described as a “slaughter house” by his lawyer Aamer Anwar. Anwar told the Sunday Mail: “On Thursday, the First Minister John Swinney and Health Secretary Angela Constance claimed they had not seen Dr Habib’s whistleblowing correspondence prior to November 19.

“However an email chain from 12, 13, and 19th July 2023 makes it perfectly clear that the 2022 expert report of Professor Wigmore was ‘shared and discussed’ with the then-Chief Medical Officer Gregor Smith and Cabinet Secretary for Health Humza Yousaf in October 2022.

“This means the Scottish Government knew about multiple avoidable deaths four years ago.

“Subsequent letters from Dr Habib to the First Minister and Health Secretaries should have caused alarm, or at the very least captured their attention.

“In his letter in June 2023, Dr Habib wrote an email to then-Health Secretary and First Minister with the subject heading ‘Requesting Public Inquiry for very large number of avoidable deaths’.

“This evidence raises a variety of difficult and obvious questions for the government which must now provide full details and recorded minutes of the critical meeting in October 2022.

“Surely the 2022 report and Government meeting should have been the final red flag? The concerns of Dr. Habib were not fantasy but backed up in a report in 2022.

“Can the present First Minister John Swinney and Health Secretaries explain why they had not seen Dr Habib’s letters from 2023 onwards.”

He added: “Dr Habib, frontline staff and most importantly the bereaved, deserve answers, they deserve the full glare of public scrutiny to be shone on this scandal, anything less would be a betrayal of those who died.”

Review ordered after leaked report

Dr Habib claims he contacted the Scottish Government on four separate occasions and had gone to the police and the lord advocate with his concerns about patient safety. The review was ordered after a damning 2022 report leaked by Habib found 19 of the 31 deaths in liver and pancreatic surgery cases were avoidable.

He has claimed two people died after having the wrong procedure performed on them and has called for the health board to face a corporate homicide inquiry. Health Secretary Angela Constance has insisted the review announced yesterday will assess how concerns raised about liver, gallbladder and bile duct surgery, including those by Habib, were handled by the board and the Scottish Government.

However, responding to news of the review Anwar said: “An independent review cannot mean a reshuffling of the deck chairs on the Titanic, the proof will be in the detail.

“It is clear that misleading information has been provided repeatedly to the Scottish Government by some in NHS Grampian - on that basis alone the Chief Executive cannot be allowed to continue in post, the Board should be asked to resign and the special measures of Stage 5 implemented immediately.

“The Scottish Government uses the term ‘independent review’, but nothing less than the full public inquiry demanded as far back as 2023 by Dr Habib will do.

“What status will this review have? What are its powers? Who will head the Inquiry, whom will they report to; they cannot be linked in any way to the alleged industrial scale cover-up.

“Parliament must be advised of this Inquiry’s actual mandate, its terms of reference, individual powers, its advisory panel of experts, investigative authority and ability to compel disclosure of documents, patient records, emails, serious adverse event reports, but also whether they can take evidence from families and whistleblowers.”

Patient and official responses

One patient Derek Appleton has told how he believes mistakes were made during a procedure to remove 60 per cent of his liver after being diagnosed with stage four cancer. He said he lost 11 litres of blood and went into cardiac arrest.

Health Secretary Angela Constance said: “The allegations that have been raised by Dr Habib are deeply concerning and of the utmost seriousness.

“My thoughts are with anyone who has lost a loved one and I am acutely aware of the courage it has taken Dr Habib to come forward.”

A spokesperson for Humza Yousaf said: “Humza’s thoughts are with patients and families in the North East who will be deeply anxious after this week’s news.

“They deserve full and honest answers from NHS Grampian about what has happened. Humza supports full transparency about what happened at NHS Grampian.”

The NHS Grampian allegations come a week after a scathing report found poor leadership and culture at the board. Habib has said he formally reported serious concerns about dozens of avoidable deaths in 2021. In 2024, he took 20 cases from the previous decade to the police but no charges were brought.

Detective Superintendent Carron McKellar said: “We received a report in 2024 following several deaths. Enquiries are being carried out, and a situational report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.” A spokesperson for the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) said the concerns raised by the surgeon were “taken seriously”.