A coroner has condemned NHS staff following the death of five-month-old Esta High from meningitis, after medics dismissed her symptoms as Covid and repeatedly failed to carry out blood tests that could have detected the infection earlier. The inquest jury concluded that neglect contributed to her death and that appropriate care would probably have "saved or prolonged her life."
Missed Opportunities in Hospital Care
Parents Lynsey Carr, 39, and Leon High, 43, took Esta to Leeds General Infirmary after she became ill with a high temperature and vomiting. She tested positive for Covid, and medical staff sought to discharge her but agreed to admit her following desperate pleas from her parents.
Esta spent two days in hospital before doctors discovered she had meningitis, but by then it was too late, and she died four days later. The inquest heard there were numerous missed opportunities to escalate concerns regarding her deteriorating condition, conduct blood tests, and administer life-saving antibiotics.
Coroner's Findings and Prevention Report
Jurors at Wakefield Coroner's Court established there was a period of approximately 12 hours during which the infant received no medical review prior to her death. Assistant Coroner Naomi McLoughlin has since issued a Prevention of Future Deaths report demanding that Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust outline what steps it intends to take to address her concerns.
The coroner cautioned there had "not been sufficient educational and awareness work completed" among staff regarding the possibility of children experiencing a bacterial infection alongside a viral illness. She also expressed concerns that clinicians treating children moved from the emergency department did not have complete access to earlier patient records, which could leave medics unaware of observations and monitoring already undertaken, potentially delaying treatment and placing patients at risk.
Parents' Response and Legal Action
Esta's parents welcomed the coroner's findings. Lynsey said: "When Esta was in hospital we knew something wasn't right. We knew our daughter. We knew what she was normally like and we could see that this wasn't our baby. All we wanted was for our concerns to be listened to and for her to receive the care she needed and deserved. We were Esta's voice but we weren't listened to and were made to feel like anxious parents who were overreacting. That is incredibly difficult to live with because the inquest has now established that we were right to be concerned about our baby girl."
Medical negligence lawyer Joe Haley, of Irwin Mitchell, said: "Lynsey and Leon remain devastated by Esta's death and how when she needed help the most they believe she was badly let down. Nothing can bring their daughter back but all Lynsey and Leon want is to ensure no stone is left unturned in improving care to help other families. The care improvements the coroner has identified are fundamental patient safety issues. Lives could be at risk if these concerns aren't addressed. The Trust now needs to show that it has listened to the coroner's concerns and that lasting improvements will follow."
Timeline of Esta's Final Days
Esta was brought to the hospital's emergency department on October 31, 2023, before being moved to the children's assessment and treatment unit later that same day. Over the next two days her condition deteriorated and she began experiencing seizures. The coroner stated there were periods during which her care was not escalated as it should have been.
She was transferred to paediatric intensive care on November 3, where she received a meningitis diagnosis and tests confirmed signs of brain injury. Despite receiving treatment, Esta's condition continued to worsen and she passed away in her parents' arms on November 6.
In a tribute, Lynsey said: "Nothing will ever bring Esta back or take away the pain of losing our little girl. We have to live with that every day. She will never take her first steps, say her first words or start school, and that's something we'll never really come to terms with."
Leon said: "One of the hardest things for us is knowing that during Esta's care there were points when other possibilities and concerns about something more serious were considered, but they were not acted on. It needs to mean acting on those concerns, investigating them properly and continuing to question the diagnosis when a child is deteriorating. Esta was our world and we owe it to her to honour her memory by campaigning for change. We can't change what happened to Esta, but we can keep asking the difficult questions and pushing for lessons to be learned so that another family doesn't find themselves where we are. Changes need to be made to ensure this doesn't keep happening, no other family should have to go through what we have and no other child should lose their life."
Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust is required to respond to the coroner by December 16, outlining what steps it has taken or intends to take to prevent further deaths. Dr Elizabeth Garthwaite, Chief Medical Officer at Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, said: "We offer our deepest sympathies to Lynsey and Leon and their family for the tragic loss of Esta. We recognise the profound and ongoing impact of Esta's death on her family, and their need to understand what happened."