Disabled day centre users in Barry say move plan treats them as 'second class citizens'
Barry disabled day centre users hit out at 'second class' move plan

Disabled day service users in the Vale of Glamorgan say they are being treated "like second class citizens" over plans to move their centre. New Horizons, which operates out of Hen Goleg on College Fields Close in Barry, provides a day service for people who are permanently and substantially physically disabled, with activities including a gym, a craft room and a woodwork section.

Vale of Glamorgan council wants to move the centre to a new building on Thompson Street, and some centre-goers say that represents a downgrade in both the building and the services. Currently, both New Horizons and Woodlands, a learning disability day service, are located in Hen Goleg, with the building split between them. Both are planned to be moved into the Thompson Street building.

Members voice concerns over shared spaces

Mark Roderick, 51, who uses the centre, said: "In the proposed move to Thompson Street, it's an open plan area where we'll be using shared spaces. We have one designated room which is ours, but the rest of the whole building is open plan and not designated to anyone."

Mark continued: "This is highly inappropriate because we have very different requirements and we feel that priority has been given to those with learning disabilities." He also said that multiple members of New Horizons feel as if the council overlooked them when considering the proposal and has not listened to their concerns.

Julie Brown, 61, said she was "absolutely distraught" at the idea of moving buildings, as New Horizons is a "lifeline" for her. She added: "I think a lot of people won't come to a new place. A lot of people will stop coming because they're treating us like second class citizens, I think they could treat us a lot better than what they are."

Social lifeline at risk

The centre plays an important part in the social life of many of its members, but some fear the new building could change that. Joan Pritchard, 82, said it comprised "all of it". She continued: "The whole idea for me was to come out and meet with people, to talk to them because [in the past] I didn't see anybody. If I can't do that, like meeting people in the craft room for instance, or going to the gym, then it's not worth it, it's not worth me attending."

Ian McDonald, a carer who looks after a centre member, shared similar concerns. He said: "Most of the people up here accept the move, all they want is what they've got now. Just to try and keep the gym, the woodwork shop and all the things they've got now." Ian added that he believes the person he cares for will be less likely to want to go to the new centre.

The centre also means a lot to Mandy Storm, 68. "Since I've come here, I am more of a person. I've learnt how to banter and I've learned how to take jokes whereas I didn't know banter or jokes [before]." She continued that although moving to the Thompson Street building would not, in her opinion, affect her ability to socialise with others at New Horizons, she agrees with the concerns raised by other members of the day centre. She added: "I wish I'd known about this place years ago."

Council defends move as modernisation

Vale of Glamorgan cabinet member for social care and health, Cllr Eddie Williams, said: "We know the New Horizons service is highly valued by the people who use it, their families and the staff who support them. As the only local authority in Wales that continues to provide a service of this kind, we also recognise how important it is to the wider community, and understand that any proposed change may naturally bring some uncertainty."

"The current building shared by New Horizons and Woodlands Day Services faces significant challenges and is no longer considered to be a sustainable or suitable environment to support the long-term future of the services. The proposed move to Thompson Street in Barry is about creating modern, sustainable services that bring together adult social care, health professionals, and specialist support services in one accessible town centre hub."

"By bringing services together in one location, service users will have easier access to support, greater opportunities for independence and stronger links with other Council and community services. While the proposed new building may not be able to accommodate all of the existing larger-scale activities, we are actively exploring alternative ways to continue providing opportunities and experiences that are important to service users."

"Importantly, there are no plans to reduce the quality of support people receive or change the dedicated staff teams that service users know and trust. Our aim is to deliver the best possible service right in the heart of Barry and we will continue listening to service users, their families, carers and staff as plans progress."

"We have worked closely with service users and their representatives over several years to consider alternative proposals, and more recently, the development of this property. This is an ongoing process, which will continue to help shape both the final plans and how the service is delivered in the future, ensuring their views remain a vital part of the project."