Gardening expert Alan Titchmarsh has cautioned gardeners against wholesale cutting back of perennials in autumn borders this November, warning that the common chore can harm both plants and wildlife.
The former Gardeners' World presenter and Love Your Garden host explained that removing dead foliage may tidy up a garden, but it can also deprive garden creatures of essential winter food sources while weakening healthy plants.
Be Selective, Don't Hack Everything Back
Offering guidance on his Gardening With Alan Titchmarsh YouTube channel, he stated: "Come November, you might be tempted to wade right through your borders, hacking everything back. Don't. Be selective."
Rather than clearing an entire flowerbed in one session, the 77-year-old gardening authority recommended taking a plant-by-plant strategy. Some spent perennials, such as nepeta, can be safely cut down once they have completed flowering for the season.
"Things like this catnip here, they peter, that's pretty much finished, and you can certainly hack into that with your shears and take it back as far as you want," he outlined.
Leave Green Growth and Food for Birds
Other perennials, though, are still actively sustaining themselves and the broader garden ecosystem. Highlighting hardy geraniums, Alan observed that removing healthy foliage prematurely does more harm than good.
"But when it comes to things like this geranium here, there's a lot of green growth on that still. Be selective on what you're cutting off there," he said. "These straggling shoots down the front, you can take those off, but leave that central green growth. Leave also any plants which are going to offer food to the birds through winter."
He added: "Things like eryngium, Sea holly and grasses which look wonderful when the frost is on them and the winter sun set low is shining through them. So by all means cut off things which you now are not going to be any use to wildlife and any use to you to look at, but do it bit by bit."
A Simple Guideline for Pruning
For those uncertain which plants to prune and which to keep intact, Alan provided a simple guideline: "If a plant is dying back and looking brown, you can cut it off almost to ground level. If it's green and still growing, leave it. It'll feed the roots by sending the nutrition down. And you're robbing it of doing that if you take off good green growing foliage."
Reassuring gardeners that vigorous clumps without dead centres do not require lifting or splitting just yet, he concluded: "These are still healthy plants, and they'll go through the winter happily like that."