England's water industry watchdog attended just one in six pollution incidents reported this year, according to figures obtained through a Freedom of Information request.
The Environment Agency failed to attend thousands of incidents in the first nine months of this year where water firms were deemed responsible. Some are believed to include illegal discharges of raw sewage, potentially into rivers and the sea. This comes despite a near £190 million jump in the agency's funding last year and its budget rising to more than £2.4 billion this year.
The water industry has already faced public anger over its track record on tackling what is seen as a sewage scandal. A report from Ofwat at the end of October rated eight of England's nine water companies as "poor" or "requiring improvement".
Data reveals attendance gaps
The figures were revealed through Freedom of Information data obtained by Rob Forrester, a former Environment Agency inspector turned whistleblower. His identity was revealed in Channel 4's docu-drama Dirty Business, about the fight by campaigners Ash Smith, played by David Thewlis, and Peter Hammond, played by Jason Watkins, to expose the truth about sewage pollution.
The data shows that in the first nine months of this year there were 5,100 pollution incidents reported to the agency that were the fault of water companies, yet the agency only attended 828.
Southern Water was responsible for the most reports of pollution this year, at 792, followed by Thames Water, at 717. Yet the agency attended 80 Southern-related reported incidents, and 81 for Thames, or around just one in 10. All the figures from the FOI are provisional and could change once finalised.
Whistleblower and political reaction
Mr Forrester said: "Pollution incidents are the more likely causes of criminal offences but if no evidence is collected then no prosecution can take place."
Pollution incidents are graded from one, the most serious, to four, the least. Mr Forrester alleges that, during his time as an officer, he was pressured to not attend incidents and downgrade them. "There was a cloud of protection around water companies," he claims. "Frontline staff were prevented from doing their job."
The Environment Agency has vowed to clean up its act, with its poor response to pollution incidents featured in Dirty Business. Mr Forrester claimed the latest data questions whether this has been the case. "Despite record funding, nothing meaningful has changed," he says. "The water companies are still not being held to account. Worryingly, this is the standard of regulation the Prime Minister is relying on for public control."
Environment Agency inspectors attended seven of the eight most serious category 1 incidents in the first nine months of this year, and 44 of the 61 in the next tier down. The bulk where it did not were those classified in the two lower categories, although Mr Forrester claims water companies can determine how they are initially classified.
Agency and company responses
Barry Gardiner, Labour MP for Brent West, said: "This data once again shows how flawed the current regulatory system is. Water companies cannot be allowed to self-report incidents - the government must urgently set out when the disaster that has been operator self monitoring will end."
"Rather than the 10,000 inspections Defra and the EA like to congratulate themselves for, the EA should be prioritising sending its agents out to inspect incidents before they get downgraded due to a lack of evidence."
"As it stands, the system allows water companies to charge record bills, raking in record returns on capital, and all the while getting away with polluting our rivers, lakes, and seas. The sooner the government acts to take the water sector back into public ownership - as supported by over 80% of the public - the better."
An Environment Agency spokesperson said: "It is wrong to suggest incidents are not investigated. Pollution levels are unacceptable and we will not hesitate to prosecute water companies that break the law. Every report is assessed, and we prioritise attending the most serious in person, where the risk to people and the environment is greatest. We have concluded over 70 prosecutions and secured £158 million in fines since 2015."
The agency added that in the 12 months to April this year, it increased its attendance at water industry incidents by 50%, and that it prioritises attending the most serious incidents in person, which are often complex. "All incidents are subject to detailed assessment using multiple sources of evidence before being categorised, ensuring robust and consistent reporting," the agency added.
A Southern Water spokesperson said: "We're tackling the root causes of pollution through our record £8.9 billion investment programme, replacing ageing assets, using technology to prevent blockages and improving power resilience at high-risk sites."
"We've already delivered significant improvements, cutting pollution incidents by almost a third between 2023 and 2025. We know no pollution incident is acceptable, and we're going as fast as we can to improve performance."
A Thames Water spokesperson said: "The figures referenced are based on incident reports logged with the Environment Agency and should not be treated as Thames Water's confirmed pollution performance for 2026."
"It is also important to note that changes to the Environment Agency reporting guidance mean this year's figures are not directly comparable with previous years."
"As reported in our 2025/26 Annual Report, total pollutions fell by 18% and serious pollutions fell by 27%. We're continuing to invest in improving environmental performance, including through our £20 billion investment programme between 2025 and 2030."