When Caroline Muirhead’s boyfriend of just a few weeks suggested they get married, the then 29-year-old pathologist knew it was something of a whirlwind, but she was ready to seize the day. ‘I had this devil-may-care attitude of “What’s the worst that can happen?” ’ she recalls of the heady romance.
Now, more than five years on, she knows all too well what the worst looks like: within days of that proposal in November 2020, Alexander McKellar, the statuesque and handsome Scottish gamekeeper for whom Caroline had fallen head over heels, had unburdened himself of a deadly secret.
He confided that, three years earlier, while drunk at the wheel, he had fatally mown down a cyclist, 63-year-old Tony Parsons, a retired former Navy officer who was on a charity bike ride on a remote Highland roadside. With the help of his twin brother Robert, he had then disposed of Parsons’ body in a desolate peat bog.
At Caroline’s request, Alexander had then taken her to the burial site, where she left an empty drinks can to mark the spot before calling the police. The discovery of Tony’s body in January 2021 brought to a close one of Scotland’s most puzzling missing persons inquiries, as well as years of anguish for his devastated wife and two grown-up children – while the arrest and eventual imprisonment of the McKellar twins in August 2023 garnered headlines around the world.
Throughout it all, however, Caroline kept her silence. Many assumed she wanted to stay out of the public spotlight. Only now has the full extraordinary truth emerged – including the price Caroline paid for sharing her terrible secret.
To read Kathryn Knight's gripping feature sign up to The Crime Desk newsletter HERE. You'll receive an email straight away with a link to read this exclusive subscriber article for free. If you are one of the 30,000 readers already signed up, you can also read it in this week's newsletter. Each week our team will bring you unrivalled insight, expert analysis, and in-depth reporting on the cases you can't stop thinking about. Every newsletter will be packed with exclusive features, interviews and the breaking stories dominating today’s headlines. Delivered to your inbox every week, completely FREE.
