Strictly Come Dancing has three new hosts, with comedian Josh Widdicombe drawing particular criticism from fans. Some viewers have labelled him a “spare part” compared with co-hosts Emma Willis and Johannes Radebe, who have generally received a warmer reception. “Wooden,” “awkward,” and “not funny” are among the complaints shared on social media.
A stacked comedy CV
While humour is subjective, Widdicombe’s comedy career is substantial. He began in stand-up in 2008, working through the circuit before his debut solo show, If This Show Saves One Life…, earned a Best Newcomer nomination at the Foster’s Edinburgh Comedy Awards in 2011. The following year he became a regular on panel shows including Mock the Week, 8 out of 10 Cats and The Last Leg, which he co-hosts.
His self-deprecating humour suits the frantic, chaotic style of panel shows, where silly anecdotes and awkward moments are part of the premise. On Strictly, standing next to the polished Willis, that style has not yet meshed with viewers.
Different roles, different expectations
Widdicombe and Willis are placed on the dance floor, in a role long held by Tess Daly, whose poised presence calmed contestants. Willis mirrors Daly’s temperament, making Widdicombe’s different style stand out. Daly’s counterpart, Claudia Winkleman, was upstairs in the fan-named Clauditorium, a position now held by Radebe, who interviews dancers after the judges’ scores.
It is clear the pros, many of whom have worked with Radebe for years, support his promotion. A switch might suit the show: Widdicombe could bring his chaotic humour to the post-scoring debriefs, away from the judges, in the less structured environment Winkleman once filled with high energy.
A new era for the show
Strictly has been on air for 24 years, and apart from Winkleman becoming main co-host after the death of Sir Bruce Forsyth, little has changed. Now there are three new hosts, five new professional dancers, and format changes to both the main show and It Takes Two. Long-term fans may find it a lot to adjust to, and it is acceptable not to love it immediately.
Only one live show has aired, with 12 more to come. Viewers, stars and production crew are still getting used to this new era. The magic of Strictly remains even if the presentation looks different, from promising new pros to YouTuber John Nellis rising as an underdog.
As for Widdicombe, starting a new job with millions ready to criticise every move would make anyone miss a cue. Showing grace to the show and backing its hosts, stars and dancers could make this another Strictly series to remember.
