Adult content creators have revealed the most extreme 'forbidden fantasies' subscribers ask them to perform, including mistress roleplay, staged encounters with hikers, and towering over tiny figurines. The revelations follow an analysis by independent search engine OnlySearch of more than 7.2 million searches over 12 months to rank the most popular taboo categories.
Cheating Fantasies Top the Rankings
Cheating-related terms, including 'hotwife' and 'cuckold', topped the selected taboo categories, attracting more than six times as many searches as step-family content. Feminisation ranked second, followed by public and outdoor fantasies in third place.
For creator Molly Little, who regularly receives requests to play a mistress and involve her partner in subscribers' fantasies, the top-ranked category comes as little surprise. She said: "Maybe some people enjoy feeling like they can get away with something they shouldn't. There's always something alluring about breaking the rules."
While Molly is comfortable playing someone else's mistress, she draws the line at pretending to betray her own partner. She continued: "I actually do not accept requests where I roleplay cheating on my boyfriend. I don't like the way it makes me feel. I don't mind playing into the cheating fetish when I can pretend I'm their mistress, but I don't like ones where I'm cheating on my partner."
Outdoor Scenarios and Staged Encounters
OnlySearch's rankings also placed swinging sixth, suggesting interest in scenarios involving other partners extends beyond cheating-themed searches. Molly says some requests involve relationships where everyone knows about one another, including one subscriber who wanted to add an imaginary third partner.
"One man actually has a wife and a girlfriend in real life - they know about each other - and he requested a video where I was acting as a third girlfriend, but leading the bedroom scenario, telling everyone what to do and when to do it," she said.
For Canadian creator Isla Moon, whose niche is outdoor content, it's no surprise that public and outdoor fantasies ranked third. Isla says the fantasy of being 'caught' has become so popular that she had to recruit her partner Andrew to play a passing stranger. "There was a point around 2023 where all my fans wanted was content of me getting caught, and I didn't want to do a real version of that," she said. "I often made videos with my partner Andrew where he would dress up in a way that it didn't look like him."
Giantess Fantasy and Other Top Categories
Some of Isla's most popular content comes from the pair's staged storylines around their camping and fishing trips. "The storylines were that I would get caught by a hiker who was hiking by," she explained. "The hiker thing was huge for us, and I will be bringing it back this month." She also revealed that some of her most consistent requests involve her outdoor equipment.
"For some reason guys love when I film with anything motorized… my snowmobile, fishing boat, Jeep," she said. "Maybe it's the sense of danger or something." Isla believes the appeal comes from placing an intimate moment somewhere unexpected. "I think there's something naturally exciting about taking something that's usually considered private and putting it in a setting where you wouldn't expect it," she said. "There's that little sense of taboo and freedom that makes it feel more spontaneous and real."
OnlySearch's rankings also included fart fetish in fourth place and gloryhole in fifth, followed by swinging, step-family, watersports and financial domination. The combined 'vore / giantess' category rounded out the top 10.
For creator Amelia Quest, the giantess fantasy means subscribers want to imagine themselves small and submissive in comparison to her. "They definitely focus on being tiny next to me," she said. "They wanna feel like they're two inches tall." Amelia shared that one subscriber simply wanted a series of everyday comparisons. "I once had a man ask me to stand in front of different household objects, so he could see how tall I was relative to them," she said.
Other requests require a more elaborate storyline, and even a miniature stand-in for the subscriber. "I once had someone ask me to make a video where I used a little figurine that kind of looked like them to floss in between my toes," she said. "I had to step on him so hard that when I lifted my foot up he was embedded into the soul. Then I scraped him off into the garbage."
For Molly, the variety of requests reflects how difficult some people find discussing their fantasies with a partner. "I think that when a person has a sexual fantasy they would like to try out or do, it is vulnerable, and explaining that to a partner can be scary," she said. "It makes sense that a person would turn to online content to fulfil that fantasy."
