Hundreds of schools in Wales are carrying over ever-growing deficits each year and struggling to balance the books, with the most indebted owing as much as £10,000 for every pupil and finishing the year more than £2m in the red.
Headteachers describe a gloomy picture of leaking roofs, classes at capacity, staff redundancies and even worrying about the cost of loo roll. They warn that the soaring bill for children with additional needs is taking a wrecking ball to school finances.
Heads describe 'broken' funding system
The problems are the same in rural and urban areas as school management grapples to balance budgets. School leaders describe rising bills, dwindling real terms income and increased statutory demands on what they call a "broken" funding system.
The head of one school in a relatively affluent area but "in serious deficit" said: "We are genuinely struggling to afford everyday essentials, including paper, stationery and even toilet rolls." She added that the school relies heavily on its PTA and the generosity of families, including support through an Amazon wish list, to provide resources many would assume schools can readily afford.
Staff cuts and ALN pressures
Another headteacher, working to shave off his school's £200,000 deficit from the last financial year, lists how he has lost his assistant head, two teachers and a teaching assistant in recent redundancies, and fears more job losses to come. With staff amounting to 90% of school costs, it is the first place to look for savings.
Heads say children without additional needs are not achieving as well as they could because so much time, effort and money now goes on soaring numbers of pupils with additional needs and new legal duties around that. They stress they do not blame children but politicians who tell schools what they must legally provide and then don't fund it.
One head, after 15 years in the job, is distraught that most of his time is spent fire fighting with scant funds rather than concentrating on the best education for all pupils. He and other headteachers asked not to be identified for fear of reprisals.
'100% the reason for the deficits are ALN costs'
One headteacher said: "The roof leaks and the carpets are coming up, everybody is suffering." He said the "huge rise" in children with additional needs and changes in the law is the cause of most school deficits in Wales. "100% the reason for the deficits are ALN costs, there will be a few outliers but most school deficits will be caused by ALN. My deficit is £200,000. My school's costs are between £40,000 and £70,000 more than my ALN budget each year now."
Another head agrees, saying: "A substantial proportion of our costs arise from providing the support that children with additional needs require to access education safely and appropriately. We have a recovery plan in place, but achieving financial stability within current funding levels while maintaining the provision our pupils require is unrealistic. Inevitably, we will have to reduce staffing over the next three years."
Heads point to multiple possible reasons for increased numbers of ALN children, including greater understanding and diagnosis of neurodiversity, social and family trauma, and the negative impact of social media and poverty. One head said: "Ten years ago among 300 children three children would not be suited to school learning. Now it is three in 30."
Funding distribution concerns
Schools in more affluent areas are struggling as well as those in less advantaged places. Those with a relatively low percentage of pupils eligible for free school meals (FSM) get considerably less Pupil Development Grant funding than many other schools. "A low FSM figure does not mean a low level of need," points out one headteacher affected.
She said: "I fully recognise the importance of additional funding to tackle poverty. However, funding systems must also recognise that children can have significant additional learning, wellbeing and safeguarding needs regardless of their eligibility for free school meals." She added that savings have included turning down professional learning opportunities for teachers, and she is considering whether the school can continue providing swimming lessons because of transport costs.
"At its heart, this is not about budgets or balances on a spreadsheet. It is about children. Every decision we make has a direct impact on their experiences, opportunities and future prospects, and that is what makes the current situation so difficult," she said.
Welsh Government response
The National Association of Headteachers Cymru has criticised the Welsh Government's decision not to have passed on all funding for ALN under the Barnett Formula. The NAHT said £60m in additional ALN funding has been passed on to schools, less than the full £322m they should be entitled to under money sent under the Barnett formula as a result of extra special educational needs funding in England.
A Welsh Government spokesperson said: "We are pleased that the Senedd agreed the supplementary budget which will deliver an additional £60m in 2026-27 to support ALN learners in schools and colleges, the vast majority of which has gone direct to schools. This funding will help reduce workload and support teacher well-being, and we are ready to resume discussions on related matters with NAHT Cymru and employers at any time."
The spokesperson added: "As a new administration, we were informed that our public services were facing severe in-year pressures in 2026-27, with the NHS alone facing a net deficit of over £300m. In response, we are delivering historically-high levels of savings and efficiencies to ensure the sustainability of services this year and beyond. Devolution means Welsh Ministers decide how funding is spent in Wales based on the nation's needs and priorities. We will publish our draft budget for 2027-2028 and beyond later this month. Consequential funding has been used, in line with our responsibilities as a devolved government, to mitigate the significant pressures on all of our public services."