Eddie Lee Sexton, a self-styled Satanist, subjected his 12 children to years of rape, torture and sexual abuse, brainwashing them to the point that they killed on command in what has been described as a “private horror story.”
Sexton died in a Florida prison in 2010, 16 years after his 1994 murder conviction. His family were left living with the trauma of what he inflicted on them.
Reign of Terror and Abuse
Reports of rapes and beatings brought police to Sexton's rural Ohio home in 1992. But this was the beginning of his horror story, he then got out and subjected his family to a new living nightmare, taking them across the country and forcing them to kill each other.
Sexton grew up in a religious family, according to Lowell Cauffiel’s House of Secrets. His father was a part-time Baptist preacher. At 19, Sexton carried out an armed robbery on a gas station, landing him in prison.
There he met his future wife Estella May, who he then began to physically abuse. May sought refuge with her sister from her boyfriend's beatings, but Sexton simply threatened to kill her entire family.
“'I didn't want anybody hurt because of me, so I went back,'” she told Cauffiel. At one point Sexton was a self-appointed minister at a failed storefront church. “'The only people in the congregation were Eddie's family and a couple of friends,'” his brother, Otis Sexton said.
Brainwashing and Control
The family home was in Canton, Ohio. Babysitters said they found the children naked, locked in their bedrooms, sitting in darkness. At his trial, four of his children said they were whipped daily and impregnated his daughters. “He said he was Satan and a warlock because he had only two lines in the palm of his hand,” son Matthew Sexton said.
Daughter Estella “Pixie” Sexton Good told the jury she was 13 when Eddie Lee Sexton first raped her. He fathered two of her children. Daughter Michelle Sexton recounted being dressed in white for a “marriage” to her father at age 13. He chipped her tooth once when she refused oral sex.
The sons said Sexton forced them to stand naked while he compared their genitalia. Sexton gave each school-age child money to bribe them to tell him if they told any of their teachers what was happening.
“The only good snitch was a dead snitch,” was Sexton's mantra, youngest son Christopher testified. Estella May once held one of the children down once while her Sexton raped her.
Escape and Murder
The abuse stayed secret until 1992 when one daughter told her school counsellor what was happening. Police and the Stark County Department of Family Services investigated, but Sexton denied any wrongdoing.
Sexton barricaded himself in the house when police knocked on his door and armed himself with a 20-gauge shotgun, 357-magnum handgun and 70 rounds of ammunition.
After six gruelling hours, he surrendered, was jailed several days and was then released. He fled Ohio, and took his family with him. They fled to a trailer at a state park near Tampa, Florida, in October 1993. Then, his daughter Sexton Good’s baby fell sick.
The baby’s cries infuriated Sexton, who threatened to silence the 9-month-old unless his daughter did, so she suffocated her child. The baby was buried clutching a pacifier and rattle.
Sexton Good's husband, Joel Good, was a quiet, kind man with a learning disability. Joel was distraught, and Sexton thought he was a flight risk. Sexton blamed his son, Willie, for strangling Good with a hand-made garrote in the woods, some weeks after Skipper's death.
However, Willie Sexton said he killed Good on his father's orders. On January 14, 1994, FBI agents working with Florida and Ohio police, found Sexton at a supermarket parking lot. Shortly after, authorities found the bodies of Good and his son buried in separate state parks.
Aftermath and Convictions
A jury convicted Sexton of Good's murder and he was sentenced to death in 1994. He appealed, was granted a second trial and found guilty again.
Estella May Sexton was first convicted on sexual abuse charges in 1994 and sentenced to two years in prison. She was convicted on additional sexual abuse charges, including complicity to rape, in 1996 and sentenced to life in prison but died in 2017 after serving 23 years.
Willie Sexton, who suffered from mental health issues, was originally ruled incompetent to stand trial, but pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in 1998.
Sexton Good pleaded guilty to manslaughter in 1994 and was sentenced to 12 years in prison. Terrana said the Sextons “weren't outlaws. They weren't robbing banks and raping strangers. Everything was kept within the family.”
“They weren't a crime family, per se, in terms of committing fraud and stealing money. They didn't mess with other people. It was their own private horror story.”