Ohio 'Satan' father who brainwashed children to kill dies in prison
Ohio 'Satan' father who brainwashed children to kill dies

Eddie Lee Sexton, an Ohio father convicted of murder in 1994, spent years sexually abusing and psychologically controlling his 12 children, brainwashing them to such a degree that they killed on command in what has been described as a "private horror story." Sexton died in a Florida prison in 2010, 16 years after his murder conviction, but his family were left to carry the burden of the trauma he had inflicted upon them.

Abuse and Control

Sexton was a "very calculated, very controlling and just a really, really dark person," according to his former defence attorney Rick Terrana, as referenced in court documents. Reports of rapes and beatings first drew police to Sexton's rural Ohio home in 1992. Yet this was merely the beginning of his reign of terror — upon his release, he subjected his family to a fresh nightmare, dragging them across the country and compelling them to commit acts of violence against one another.

"It sounds like this man did not have a conscience at all," psychologist Christine Courtois says. "He knew what he was doing, and he was doing it anyway."

Background and Early Crimes

Sexton was raised in a religious household, according to Lowell Cauffiel's House of Secrets, with his father serving as a part-time Baptist preacher. At just 19 Sexton carried out an armed robbery at a petrol station, which landed him behind bars. It was there he encountered his future wife Estella May, whom he subsequently began to physically abuse. May sought sanctuary with her sister to escape her partner's violent outbursts, but Sexton responded by threatening to murder her entire family.

"'I didn't want anybody hurt because of me, so I went back,'" she told Cauffiel. At one point Sexton served as a self-styled minister at an unsuccessful storefront church. "'The only people in the congregation were Eddie's family and a couple of friends,'" his brother, Otis Sexton said.

Testimony and Escalation

The family lived in Canton, Ohio. Babysitters reported discovering the children unclothed, confined to their bedrooms and left sitting in the dark. During his trial, four of his children testified they were beaten daily, and he had impregnated his daughters. "He said he was Satan and a warlock because he had only two lines in the palm of his hand," son Matthew Sexton said. Daughter Estella "Pixie" Sexton Good informed the jury she was 13 when Eddie Lee Sexton first sexually assaulted her. He fathered two of her children.

Daughter Michelle Sexton described being dressed in white for a "marriage" to her father at the age of 13. He chipped her tooth on one occasion when she refused oral sex. The sons said that Sexton compelled them to stand unclothed while he compared their genitalia. Sexton handed each school-age child money to bribe them into reporting back to him if they disclosed anything to their teachers. "The only good snitch was a dead snitch," was Sexton's mantra, youngest son Christopher testified. Estella May once restrained one of the children while Sexton carried out a rape.

Florida State University criminology professor Emma Fridel told A&E True Crime that parents such as Sexton maintain control over their children by cutting them off from the outside world. The effect on children is "they are conditioned since birth to believe what their parent is saying. They're also conditioned by abuse when they try to deviate from any of the commands, and they're conditioned to obey," said Fridel.

Flight and Murder

The abuse remained hidden until 1992 when one daughter disclosed the situation to her school counsellor. Police and the Stark County Department of Family Services launched an investigation, but Sexton refused to admit any wrongdoing. Sexton fortified himself inside the property when officers came to his door, arming himself with a 20-gauge shotgun, 357-magnum handgun and 70 rounds of ammunition. Following six exhausting hours, he gave himself up, was imprisoned for several days before being released. He fled Ohio, taking his entire family with him.

The family escaped to a trailer at a state park near Tampa, Florida, in October 1993. It was there that his daughter Sexton Good's infant became ill. The baby's crying enraged Sexton, who threatened to silence the nine-month-old unless his daughter did, so she suffocated her child. The infant was laid to rest clutching a pacifier and rattle. Sexton Good's husband, Joel Good, was a gentle, mild-mannered man with a learning disability. Joel was devastated, and Sexton considered him a flight risk. Sexton held his son, Willie, responsible for strangling Good with a hand-made garrote in the woods, several weeks following Skipper's death. However, Willie Sexton claimed he murdered Good following instructions from his father.

On 14 January 1994, FBI agents collaborating with Florida and Ohio police located Sexton in a supermarket car park. Soon afterwards, officers discovered the remains of Good and his son interred in different state parks.

Aftermath and Sentencing

Terrana was assigned to defend Sexton and characterised him as "very soft-spoken, quiet, but you could tell he was very smart-he wasn't dumb-and very calculated in what he said and how he said it." His family, though, were plainly troubled. Terrana said: "You couldn't have a lucid conversation with them. It was sad. Pixie just had those eyes. Those million-mile eyes staring at nothing. There was no emotion. It didn't matter what you asked, what the subject was. There was nothing there. Willie had a stare like he didn't know what world he was in." Sexton "always had the same expression, which was just a bit of a grin," Terrana said. Yet Sexton's incarceration altered little. "Were they still scared to death of him? Absolutely," Terrana said.

Courtois said victims of incest endure "huge betrayal trauma" despite it being "not an uncommon situation." She said: "But what make this case more difficult is the issue of killing off a child, and killing the child's father and engaging his children to do that. All of that is way, way out on the spectrum of psychopathy." A jury found Sexton guilty of Good's killing and he was handed a death sentence in 1994. He lodged an appeal, was granted a retrial and was once again found guilty. Estella May Sexton was initially convicted on sexual abuse charges in 1994 and given a two-year prison term. She was subsequently convicted on further sexual abuse charges, including complicity to rape, in 1996 and handed a life sentence, but died in 2017 having served 23 years behind bars. Willie Sexton, who struggled with mental health problems, was originally deemed unfit to stand trial, but pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in 1998. Sexton Good pleaded guilty to manslaughter in 1994 and received a 12-year prison sentence. Terrana noted that the Sextons "weren't outlaws. They weren't robbing banks and raping strangers. Everything was kept within the family. They weren't a crime family, per se, in terms of committing fraud and stealing money. They didn't mess with other people. It was their own private horror story."