Bethany Haines, 29, has spent more than a decade searching for the remains of her father, David Haines, a British aid worker kidnapped in Syria and executed by ISIS in 2014. His body has never been recovered. Now, an anonymous informer known as 'The Wickrman' has contacted her claiming to know where her father's remains are buried and provided rough coordinates for a possible burial site.
David Haines, a former RAF aircraft engineer from Perth in Scotland, was captured while carrying out humanitarian work in Syria. He was held by a group nicknamed 'the Beatles' by hostages because of their British accents. In June 2014, his family received a handwritten ransom letter from him asking for one million euros. He was executed at the age of 44 on September 13, 2014, with footage of his killing posted online by terrorist Mohammed Emwazi, known as Jihadi John.
How the anonymous informer made contact
Beth received a message on Twitter during the 2022 trial of two of her father's captors, Alexanda Kotey and El Shafee Elsheikh, in Virginia. Initially sceptical, she was asked to download Wickr, an end-to-end encrypted messaging service with expiring messages that doesn't allow screenshots. The informer introduced himself as someone involved in the case who had seen her at court and wanted to help.
At first, the source provided general background information available on Google, but then began discussing 'the Beatles' and details of their actions that were not public knowledge at the time. He described an interaction between Emwazi and David Haines just before the execution: David told Emwazi to remove the watch he was wearing so that it would not reveal details about himself or their location in the reflection. Emwazi then removed his watch. Beth later had details of the exchange confirmed by the prosecutor's office, adding credibility to the informer's claims.
The source, known as the Wickrman, also gave Beth rough coordinates he said had been shared with him by Elsheikh, claiming it was where the remains of her father, Alan Herring and James Foley were located.
Search efforts stall amid access restrictions
Beth said her efforts to have the area fully searched have stalled, with organisations yet to receive permission to use specialist equipment at the site. She contacted the charity Hostage International, which connected her with the Syrian Justice and Accountability Centre. The centre used satellite imagery and their contacts, and had good access at the time as the area was under Kurdish control. However, the area was then taken over by the regime and a military installation was made close by.
Beth said: "I was told it could be years before we ever get access. That was hard. At that point I thought I can't do this anymore. Then Assad was taken down and it went back to Kurdish control." But then al-Jolani, now known as Ahmed al-Sharaa, went into power in 2024. She added: "We were told, at the moment, we can't get in. They don't want anyone finding bodies in Syria at the moment. It's not easily accessible anymore. You can't just go wherever you want now. They're clamping down on everything so we're stuck, waiting, and trying to negotiate."
The centre has said there wasn't clear surface evidence of a burial, and satellite imagery doesn't show the kinds of disturbances expected from previous ISIS graves. But the organisation wants to return with specialist equipment to explore further due to the source's credibility.
Confronting a captor and seeking answers
In 2022, Beth watched the full court proceedings of Kotey and Elsheikh and read a victim impact statement. She later demanded a visit of her own after learning that American families had been given permission to visit Kotey in prison. She said: "I said I'm going there solely to get information, I'm not going in as a family member of someone who's been killed. He tried to shake my hand but I wouldn't have touched it. I got straight into the questions, grilling him."
The final question she wanted to ask him was whether he had regrets and was sorry. Beth said: "He turned around and said 'you can't inherit an apology'. He explained that the person he wanted to apologise to is dead." Kotey denied any knowledge about the coordinates given to her by the Wickrman. He repeated he was working for the external security department of ISIS when the executions occurred.
Beth also got to know Federico Motka, who had been kidnapped alongside her father. She said: "I'd heard my dad was tortured, I'd heard he'd been waterboarded, but no one would confirm it. He told me details of what had happened, I could see him reliving the experience and the light left his eyes."
Ongoing investigation and hope for answers
In 2019, Beth went to Syria to "see the destruction" and speak to the Kurdish forces fighting ISIS. She was unable to participate in ITV News' confrontation with Kotey and Elsheikh due to talks of a trial in the United States. The men refused to reveal the location of any victims.
Since then, Beth was invited to the trial of jihadist Mehdi Nemmouche by a French lawyer in 2025. The French authorities sent her around 1,300 documents from the trial which she wasn't able to gain access to previously. She is still translating them and making notes.
Beth said: "It can be hard. You have to push down the fact that this happened to your father, but it gives me a way forward. I feel like I'm helping, because it's not just about me, it's about the other families who deserve to know where their loved ones are. There's always something to do with the case and I hope we'll get there."