Archaeologists have uncovered the skeletal remains of a young man near a cathedral in Milan, northern Italy, with injuries suggesting he endured Catherine wheel torture before a botched beheading. The find, documented in the Journal of Archaeological Science, may represent the first genuine archaeological proof of a human being subjected to this form of torture.
Discovery and forensic analysis
The man, believed to have been aged between 17 and 20, was discovered by researchers from the University of Milan. Forensic examination of his skeleton revealed unusual linear fractures at the cranial base of his skull, which the researchers conclude was most probably the result of sharp force trauma inflicted by a heavy weapon during a clumsy decapitation.
It is thought the man perished during the 13th century and was interred near a Milan cathedral. His wounds were almost identical on both sides of his body, with symmetrical injuries across both arms and legs, leading scientists to conclude the damage was intentional.
Evidence of the wheel
Examining his injuries alongside historical records, researchers established that the man had been subjected to torture using the wheel, also known as the Catherine wheel or the breaking wheel. This instrument of torture was deployed to both entertain and horrify onlookers.
The wheel was widespread across Europe throughout the Middle Ages, functioning to brutally crush and snap victims' limbs. The ordeal began with a heavy wooden wheel being dropped onto the victim's limbs, commencing with the shin bones before progressing upwards. Once the body had been thoroughly battered, the shattered limbs would be threaded through the wheel's spokes or bound tightly to it with rope.
Context and significance
Blunt instruments, fire, whips, or scorching hot pincers were employed to inflict further agony, before the wheel was hoisted aloft like a banner. The barely living victim would remain suspended for days or even weeks, until they ultimately perished or were put to death.
This brutal method of torture was most commonly deployed against those convicted of particularly serious crimes, yet in northern Italy, where this body was unearthed, such punishment was typically reserved for people suspected of spreading the plague. The researchers write: "The victim of the wheel could have been considered as different by his contemporaries, and possibly this discrimination may have been the cause of his final conviction, as he could have been sacrificed, being a 'freak', by an angry crowd, as a plague spreader."