A father has described his shock after discovering 27 children abandoned without food or water at the home of a Dunfermline nanny, who has now been jailed for two years.
Amanda Mathewson, 55, was a highly recommended childminder in Fife, but her licence only allowed her to care for eight children at a time. Between 2023 and 2024, a court heard she had more than 50 children in her care. On the day of her arrest, she was looking after 27, some younger than 12 months.
The Discovery
The father, named only as Angus, told The Times how he and his wife had entrusted their two sons to Mathewson for almost two years. On August 26, 2024, his sons were supposed to be under her supervision, but another parent contacted him after seeing Mathewson at school pick-up without his children.
Angus and his wife went to the school and found that none of the trainers in Mathewson's buggy belonged to their boys. They rushed to her house, where they heard a child crying inside. After finding a back door open, they discovered five school-aged children waiting in the garden without an adult, and another 22 children inside the house unattended.
Conditions Inside
Twelve of the children that day had not yet started primary school, including a toddler crying under the kitchen table. Angus's two sons were upstairs, shut in a "boiling hot" spare room with nine other children under five, including two strapped in buggies. The windows were shut, the blinds were drawn, and the group were watching a children's programme on a TV.
Angus said he found nine children with no access to food, water, toys, or activities. "At first it was just shock and disbelief, but then just an incredible sense of duty set in," he said. "We were surrounded by distressed children who didn't recognise us, with no idea of what their needs were or what problems they had." He added: "We realised we'd just uncovered a snapshot of what had been going on here but how bad did it get?"
Sentencing
As Angus walked downstairs with his sons, Mathewson arrived back from school pick-up and collapsed. Distraught parents arrived as he called the police. Police later found that the "diaries" or "logs" Mathewson gave parents about their children's days were misleading and false. It is understood she would ask parents to text her before picking up their children so she could hide others in different rooms.
At Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court in October, Mathewson admitted wilfully neglecting, abandoning, and exposing children in a manner likely to cause them unnecessary suffering or injury to their health. On Friday, Sheriff MacRitchie sentenced her to two years in prison, telling her: "Your qualifications and experience mean you understand the developmental vulnerability of babies and young children, the need for constant supervision, (and) the obvious risks created by leaving them without an adult. The potential for catastrophic harm was enormous." He said only a prison sentence was appropriate.