An American fugitive who faked his own death can be extradited from Scotland to the United States, a sheriff has ruled. Nicholas Rossi, who claims to be Arthur Knight and a victim of mistaken identity, is wanted in Utah to face rape charges.
Sheriff Norman McFadyen said Rossi was 'as dishonest and deceitful as he is evasive and manipulative'. The final decision on his extradition now rests with Scottish ministers.
Rossi, 35, was being treated for Covid-19 when he was arrested at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow on 13 December 2021. He appeared before Edinburgh Sheriff Court via videolink on Wednesday to learn the outcome of the extradition case.
During the hearing, Rossi shouted at the sheriff, calling him a 'disgrace to justice'. The sheriff concluded that there was no legal barrier to extradition, noting that Rossi's character had 'undoubtedly complicated and extended what is ultimately a straightforward case'.
Last November, Sheriff McFadyen ruled that Rossi was indeed Nicholas Rossi, not Arthur Knight as he had claimed. Authorities in the US said Rossi was known by several aliases, including Nicholas Alahverdian, and had been involved in local politics in Rhode Island.
In December 2019, Rossi told media he had late-stage non-Hodgkin lymphoma and weeks to live. Several news outlets reported his death in February 2020, but less than two years later, he turned up in a Glasgow hospital during the pandemic. The extradition case now goes to Scottish ministers for a final decision.