Two Gwent Police officers have denied gross misconduct allegations that they failed to search the homes of two missing young women who had been involved in a fatal crash, and then lied that they had carried out the searches.
PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone appeared before a misconduct hearing at Rodney Parade in Newport on November 16, where they denied all allegations against them. The allegations relate to how they handled a missing persons report made on the day of the crash by the families of Eve Smith, who was later found dead, and Sophie Russon, who was seriously injured.
The two friends, both aged 21 and from Newport, had gone on a night out on Friday, March 3, 2023, with Rafel Jeanne-Actie, 24, and Darcy Ross, who both died, and Shane Loughlin, who was seriously injured but survived. The crash happened in the St Mellons area of Cardiff, where three people died and two were seriously injured. All of the victims were trapped in the car for 46 hours before they were found.
Allegations of Failing to Search
Stephen Morley, barrister for Gwent Police's professional standards department, told the hearing that the officers failed in their duty at the vital start of the missing persons investigation. He said searches of addresses of anyone reported missing may provide vital clues and are the prerequisite for further requests for action such as aerial searches.
Mr Morley said the officers not only failed to carry out the searches but went on to dishonestly say that they had in missing persons written reports, verbally to their superior officer, Sergeant Lesley Cheverton, and during an Independent Office for Police Complaints inquiry.
Darcy Ross's mother, Claire Ross, and Sophie Russon's father, Nathan Russon, had gone to Newport central police station to report their children missing late on Saturday afternoon, the hearing was told. Eve's mother Emma Borg and brother Zaine Smith told the hearing that the two officers had later that night come to the family home in Newport, where Eve lived, and took some details, but neither asked to, nor searched, either her bedroom or the property.
Family Accounts
Stephen Morley also told the hearing that Sophie's father Nathan Russon had told an Independent Office for Police Complaints inquiry that the two officers had come to his home the same night but had also not searched it in their hunt for his daughter, who lived there. He added that had the police asked to search his house he would not have given them permission anyway.
The hearing was told that PC Livingstone had claimed not to recall either searching, or not searching, Eve and Sophie's addresses and said she had not knowingly provided misleading information. If the allegations are found proved, they could amount to gross misconduct, which would result in the officers being dismissed from Gwent Police without notice.
The fatal accident is believed to have happened at around 2am on March 4, 2023, and the first missing person report in relation to the group was made at 7.20pm that day. The group were not found until shortly after midnight on March 6, in a wooded area off the A48 in St Mellons.
Investigation Timeline
Eve, Darcy and Sophie went out together in Newport on Friday March 3, 2023. They met three men, Rafel Jeanne, Shane Loughlin and Joel Lia at a club and then drove to a caravan in Trecco Bay, Porthcawl, for a party. There has been an ongoing Independent Office for Police Complaints investigation into the time it took Gwent Police and South Wales Police to find the group after they were reported missing.
Stephen Morley said PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone, who were on a 4pm to 3am shift on March 3 2023, went first to the home address of Sophie then Eve after their families reported them missing. Wiping away tears at times, Eve's mother Emma told the hearing the two PCs had spent no more than 14 minutes in her home in Newport, had spoken to her in the hallway of the house and never searched it.
She described how she "panicked" and was "really frightened" when she realised late on Saturday that Eve was missing and something was wrong. She had not worried earlier because she thought her daughter was staying at a friend's house on the Friday night and she often failed to charge her phone.
Attending a work event in Carmarthen on the Saturday afternoon, Eve's mother said she then spotted many missed calls from her daughter's friends and realised her daughter had not posted on social media since the previous night, which was "highly unusual". Driving back to Newport she stopped in Porthcawl to find the caravan she had been told by Eve's friends that she had gone to a party at on the Friday night.
A man and a woman were at the caravan, but unhelpful, and she also saw her daughter's bag there, she told the panel. By this time she was "very scared", she told the panel. She denied later claims from PC Hardwick that she had not been worried and said she had just not shown how alarmed she was.
Describing her daughter and Darcy, who died with her in the crash, she said: "They were very good friends, they had been friends since primary." She said they were "constantly on social media". Panel chair Ian Arundale thanked Eve's mother and brother for their evidence.
At the start of the proceedings he also offered his condolences to the families and friends of the three who lost their lives, saying: "We acknowledge the deaths of these three young adults the profound loss of their families and all who knew and loved them." The hearing continues.