Coroner issues report after pensioner's death at Grange Hospital
Coroner report after pensioner's death at Grange Hospital

A coroner has issued a prevention of future deaths report to Aneurin Bevan University Health Board over the death of a pensioner who died after two days of being sick.

Brynley John Hurford, aged 78, was admitted to the Grange University Hospital in Llanfrechfa, Cwmbran, on October 28 last year with a two-day history of excessive vomiting. His observations, blood tests and X-rays were normal, and on balance it was determined that he was suffering from constipation contributed to by gastroenteritis. Steps were taken to rehydrate him, and the following day, on October 29, he was medically fit for discharge.

Deterioration and death

At 6.49pm, his condition deteriorated and his National Early Warning Score (NEWS), a clinical tool used in hospitals to detect early signs of clinical deterioration and patient illness severity, was at six. It continued to be elevated for the rest of the night, but he continued to deteriorate and died at 2.28am on October 30.

A postmortem examination concluded that he had sustained a perforated oesophagus which on balance was due to excessive vomiting, described as a "rare and unpredictable event and, in the circumstances, unforeseeable."

Coroner's concerns

Senior coroner for Gwent, Caroline Saunders, returned a conclusion of natural causes, but said that during the course of the inquest she heard evidence which gave "rise to concern", leading her to put together a prevention of future deaths report, submitted to Aneurin Bevan University Health Board.

She wrote: "The matters of concern are as follows. From 6.49pm, when Brynley's NEWS was six, the NEWS algorithm dictated that his observations should have been repeated every 30 minutes. His NEWS continued to rise to 12 but were not repeated in line with the algorithm. There was over an hour between each set of observations.

"It was suggested at the inquest that this could have been due to staff pressures. However, I determined that delays in observations in such an obviously unwell patient, when the diagnosis was unknown was a gross failure in care. However, I also determined that in this instance more regular observations would not have altered the outcome.

"I am concerned that failing to adhere to this national observation policy may put future lives at risk."

Health board response

In response, the health board said it acknowledged the coroner's concern regarding non-compliance with the required NEWS observation frequency requirements in the case. It added: "Whilst the coroner concluded that more frequent observations would not have altered the outcome, the health board accepts that observations were not undertaken in accordance with the NEWS escalation algorithm and recognises the importance of ensuring compliance with national standards for the monitoring and escalation of deteriorating patients.

"Recognition and response to the deteriorating patient has been a strategic priority for the health board and is supported through an established deteriorating patient programme encompassing NEWS2 implementation, staff education, escalation processes, audit and governance arrangements."

Stating the action that has been taken, it said that a number of actions and controls are now in place within the acute medical unit (AMU). It listed in its response to the report: implementation of NEWS2 and improved visibility of NEWS2 scores to support shared nursing and multidisciplinary oversight, with NEWS2 rolled out to all staff on the AMU in September 2025 and compliance at 97%; NEWS2 education and training reinforced for clinical staff, including the required frequency of observations and escalation of deterioration; incorporation of NEWS2 checks into the nurse in charge checklist; a dedicated practice educator supporting staff education, competency and practice development; NEWS2 monitoring and escalation requirements forming part of local induction arrangements for registered nurses and healthcare support workers; the nurse in charge having explicit responsibility for oversight of NEWS scores across the unit; a structured escalation process in place to support documentation of the NEWS score, action taken and the clinician to whom concerns have been escalated; deteriorating patients identified through established operational safety processes; the registered nurse involved in this case provided with appropriate professional and managerial support and learning following the incident; and learning-from-incidents study days for AMU staff.