More than six years after the Premier League first made public its serious allegations against Manchester City, and over 18 months since all evidence was heard, there remains no clear timeline for a verdict. Speculation has repeatedly flared around international breaks and summers, but no decision has emerged.
No Control Over Timing
Chris Partington, a litigation solicitor from Brandsmiths, explained that the independent commission decides when the verdict is ready. "It's entirely possible that all the parties are up to date with the progress but ultimately the decision will be ready when it's ready," he told the Manchester Evening News. "The club and the league could push for determination in the off-season, but the most important thing is that the commission considers all evidence and makes a robust decision."
Partington noted that 18 months is not unusual given the volume of evidence. "The commission will want to make sure that no stone is left unturned," he added.
Two-Stage Process Likely
The verdict may be split into two stages: first determining liability, then a separate hearing on sanctions. This could extend the timeline significantly. "Typically it would be split, and more so for such a large case," Partington said. "In the first instance, it's likely to be on liability only, then they will schedule a hearing on sanction if any charges are proven."
This second hearing resembles a mini-trial, with aggravating and mitigating factors presented. "Because of these procedural steps, it can take a long time," Partington noted. "It's like a second hearing, so there are steps to comply with."
Impact on Reputation
The delay continues to tarnish City's reputation and raises questions for the Premier League. The wait could extend into a fifth season since charges were announced, with no end in sight. Partington concluded, "It's difficult to predict how long it will take, but due process must be followed."
