Death row inmate Christa Pike and her legal team have filed an emergency motion claiming she has been "isolated" on her return to prison, which they say violates an agreement meant to end 28 years of solitary confinement for her. The emergency court documents come after the botched attempt to execute her.
Surviving a botched execution
On September 30, Pike became the first-ever death row inmate to survive a lethal injection execution. She spent days unconscious and in critical condition after surviving two doses of pentobarbital allegedly administered by being jabbed with at least 10 needles.
Pike was rushed to hospital for treatment. After her legal team believed that she was brain dead on October 5, expecting her to be taken off life support the following day, Pike woke up and began speaking in full sentences.
Return to prison and isolation claims
Following a 10-day hospital stay, Pike was then returned to the Debra K. Johnson Rehabilitation Center on October 9. Pike and her legal team have now accused the Tennessee Department of Correction (TDOC) of isolating Pike from the prison population, saying this violated a 2024 settlement agreement which changed the conditions of her imprisonment.
The agreement was intended to end Pike's 28 years in solitary confinement, allowing her to be housed alongside other inmates at the facility, located on the outskirts of Nashville in the United States. Pike's legal team is arguing that her continued isolation following the execution attempt violates that agreement, while state officials say that keeping her separated from other inmates is necessary because of her medical needs and maximum-security classification.
Legal arguments and response
The emergency motion accuses the TDOC of "holding Ms Pike in indefinite isolation in the prison infirmary" where she spends her days "cut off from other inmates", PEOPLE has reported. Pike's lawyers say that officials are violating that agreement by denying Pike "the opportunity to work, eat, and otherwise socialize with any other women at DJRC" as well as her "reasonable request to be housed with other women receiving temporary medical care," according to a copy of the motion obtained by the American news outlet.
"The motion was filed on an emergency basis because each day of continued isolation causes further harm to [Pike]," added attorneys Angie Bergman, Brian Roark, and Hannah Webber of Bass Berry & Sims.
In his response to Pike's emergency motion, Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti argued that the TDOC has a "constitutional duty to offer medical care to Pike," and that she "cannot force TDOC to compromise that duty in favor of an ill-conceived housing and treatment plan" that in Skrmetti's estimation would "lead to inferior access to medical care." The Attorney General also said that Pike's desire to move to a prison pod and join the general population is not "medically appropriate".
He also said that once Pike has recovered, she can rejoin the population. Pike was set to be killed by a lethal injection at the end of September for the murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer in 1995.
In concluding his response to Pike's emergency motion, the Attorney General wrote: "The motion to enforce the Agreement should be denied. Defendants have not breached the Agreement, and Pike is not entitled to dictate the terms of her medical treatment and housing."
Next steps
A court date has now been set, with a judge hearing arguments on the case on December 1. State Governor Bill Lee called off all executions in the state for the rest of the year after the botched attempt, but did not sign a proclamation providing Pike with a stay of her execution.