Nearly one million young people across the UK are not in employment, education, or training, trapped in a cycle of failed potential and lost opportunities. The situation has been described as a profound national scandal, with little concrete action taken to address the waste of lives.
A review by former Labour minister Alan Milburn offers a bold yet compassionate blueprint to tackle the problem. Rather than leaving young adults on long-term welfare, the review argues that disability benefits should not be given to young people who could work.
Opportunity guarantee for under-25s
At the heart of the proposals is a statutory “opportunity guarantee” ensuring every under-25 has access to a job, apprenticeship, or training place. This would be paired with dedicated mental health support and personalised coaching.
By shifting resources away from benefits and reducing employer National Insurance contributions to encourage hiring, the root causes of youth joblessness could be addressed.
Concerns over Holyrood opposition
Milburn's welfare review is due to be published on November 17, with recommendations expected to affect disability benefits. However, there is a danger that constitutional point-scoring in Holyrood could halt these moves at the border.
First Minister John Swinney and the SNP have already expressed scepticism, warning against welfare reforms. Critics say this ignores the stark reality that economic inactivity is a blight on Scots, particularly those from deprived backgrounds.
Call for Scottish cooperation
Refusing to work with Labour to bring about a “work-first” system would be a grave mistake, the review argues. Real social justice is not measured by how easily young people can claim out-of-work benefits, but by how effectively they are helped to build independent, fulfilling lives.
The Scottish Government must put point-scoring aside, embrace these practical reforms and ensure no young Scot is left behind.