A seasoned adventure travel writer and gear-tester has put more than 100 pairs of boots through their paces over a decade, hiking thousands of miles from Mount Kenya to local trails in Cornwall and the Cotswolds. The only way to determine if a hiking boot is up to scratch is to put in the miles, and each pair recommended was worn on at least 10 miles of trails, including Lake District fells, the South West Coast Path, and wild-camping walks on Dartmoor. Some boots, like the Lowa Innovos, were tested over 40 miles to ensure durability.
The first criterion for picking a hiking boot is waterproofing. Each boot was stomped through puddles and squished through mud, including a detour into a Lake District bog. Boots should fit like a glove, with a snug ankle, bouncy sole, and comfy inner sole for cushioning over long distances. The boots tested for this article will be donated to the Julian Trust night shelter in Bristol.
The first decision is whether to choose leather or fabric. Leather is warm, long-lasting, and naturally waterproof, while fabric boots are lighter and more breathable but less durable. Stiff leather boots traditionally require breaking in, though many now feel comfortable out of the box. Leather needs care to prevent cracking, and insulated leather is better for winter, while breathable fabric suits warmer weather. It is advisable to invest in a pair of each for all-season hiking.
Boots should be waterproof, not just water-resistant. Water-resistant boots use DWR treatments, while waterproof boots have a membrane that blocks water but lets sweat out. Gore-Tex (GTX) is one of the best-known waterproof technologies. Always try boots on in person with hiking socks, ensuring comfort when tightly laced, with toe wriggle room and supported ankle and heel. Higher-cut boots offer ankle support for challenging terrain. Wider feet should look for wide-fit options.
Hiking boots are an exception to buying secondhand; buy new and spend as much as you can afford. New boots mould to your feet over time, and you know they are waterproof with sound soles. Decent boots cost £150 and up. Clean boots after use, treat leather regularly, and re-waterproof if needed. When boots wear out, consider donating if there is life left in them.
