The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has upheld complaints against property portal OnTheMarket and estate agency Edward Mellor after a bungalow advertised for £107,500 turned out to be a 50% shared ownership property with additional costs and restrictions.
The ruling, published today, found that two online adverts omitted information buyers needed before making an enquiry. The property, a two-bedroom semi-detached bungalow, appeared in a paid-for display advert with the headline: “2 bedroom semi-detached bungalow for sale. From £107,500”.
However, the price covered only a 50% share. Buyers would also face rental payments, service charges and insurance costs. The property was also subject to restrictions requiring residents to be aged 55 or over and retired from full-time employment. None of those conditions appeared in the initial display advert.
Advert failed to disclose shared ownership
The ASA investigated the adverts after identifying concerns about paid-for promotions for shared ownership homes. OnTheMarket argued that its display advert acted as a signpost to the full property listing, saying the linked listing clearly identified the shared ownership arrangement and explained that buyers would acquire a 50% share.
The ASA rejected that defence, ruling that buyers could reasonably interpret the £107,500 figure as the price of the entire property. The watchdog said the shared ownership arrangement significantly affected the nature of the purchase and should have appeared in the initial advert. It also rejected the argument that space restrictions justified leaving out the information.
Estate agent relied on incorrect information
The investigation also uncovered problems with the property’s advertised monthly costs. Edward Mellor initially listed rent at £325 per month, based on information supplied by the seller and housing association. However, the agency subsequently received details showing that the total monthly charge was £375.30, comprising £249.09 in rent, a £112.52 service charge and £13.70 for insurance.
The agency updated its marketing after receiving the revised information. Nevertheless, the ASA ruled that the listing should have disclosed the service charge and its amount. The watchdog also found that the listing failed to explain the eligibility requirements for shared ownership, omitting restrictions limiting occupation to people aged 55 or over who had retired from full-time employment.
‘We rely on information from sellers’
Edward Mellor told the ASA that it had relied on information provided by the seller and housing association, saying neither party had initially supplied details of the age restriction or shared ownership eligibility requirements. It also explained that estate agents do not normally undertake a full legal examination of a lease before marketing a property, relying instead on information supplied by sellers and other relevant parties.
The agency argued that it had no commercial incentive to attract enquiries from buyers who would not qualify to purchase the home. It acknowledged that eligibility and occupation restrictions were material information. It has since reviewed its procedures and said it would seek to include full shared ownership details in future listings.
Portal says it cannot verify every listing
OnTheMarket told the ASA that Edward Mellor had supplied the property listing and was responsible for its content. The portal said it could not independently verify every detail because of the volume of properties advertised on its website, and pointed to practical and technical limitations on checking listings for accuracy and completeness.
However, OnTheMarket said it would remove listings where necessary after becoming aware of problems. The portal accepted responsibility for preparing the paid-for display advert but disputed that either advert was materially misleading, arguing that buyers would not make major property decisions based solely on a display advert. The ASA disagreed, holding both businesses responsible for the paid-for display advert.
ASA orders changes to property advertising
The ASA concluded that both adverts breached advertising rules by omitting material information, finding breaches of CAP Code rules 3.1, 3.3, 3.4 and 3.4.1, which cover misleading advertising. The watchdog ordered that the adverts must not appear again in the form complained of.
It instructed OnTheMarket and Edward Mellor to ensure that future shared ownership advertising clearly identifies the arrangement and the percentage share represented by the advertised price. Edward Mellor must also ensure its listings disclose applicable service charges, eligibility criteria and occupation restrictions.
The ruling makes clear that providing important information later in the sales process does not necessarily satisfy advertising requirements. For agents marketing shared ownership homes, the advertised price is only part of the story: buyers must also be told about the costs and restrictions that determine whether they can afford, or even qualify for, the property.