A couple have abandoned their legal challenge to what they called an “unlawful” decision to change the operators of their popular cafes on Hampstead Heath.
Patrick Matthews and Emma Fernandez, a husband and wife team, run three independent cafes in the north London park. On Monday they said they would not pursue a judicial process against the City of London Corporation (CLC), which decided to hand the cafes over to a restaurant chain.
Permission Granted Before Climbdown
The climbdown came after a judge reviewed their judicial review claim and granted permission for it to proceed, having decided the claim “was arguable and should be heard”, the couple said on Monday. They added that the decision was made with “immense sadness”.
The dispute began when the CLC selected Australian-inspired group Daisy Green in December last year to run the cafes in the Queen's Park, Golders Hill Park, Parliament Hill Lido and Parliament Hill Fields areas of the Heath.
Tenancy and Possession Proceedings
Tenancy agreements for the current cafe operators were ending in February, according to the CLC. The premises were due to be taken over by the chain in the spring this year. Mr Matthews and Ms Fernandez nevertheless continued to run the premises at Parliament Hill Lido and Queen's Park, as well as in Highgate Wood.
Lawyers acting on the couple's behalf filed a judicial review claim at the High Court earlier this year, challenging the CLC's decision. In March, the CLC, which runs Hampstead Heath as a charity, announced plans to file possession proceedings to evict the couple's business, Hoxton Beach Ltd, from the premises.
The CLC accused Hoxton Beach Ltd of “refusing to leave the premises”, preventing the new operators from beginning “fit outs”, “building upgrades” and “improvements”.
Support and Statement
The couple had the backing of Sherlock star Benedict Cumberbatch and Scottish actor James McAvoy. A petition signed by 24,000 people called for the handover to be stopped.
Explaining their decision, the couple said in a statement: "The Corporation is the custodian of Hampstead Heath, Highgate Woods and Queen's Park.
"Ultimately, we cannot continue operating these cafés without the Corporation's support; the situation is unsustainable.
"The personal and financial costs have become too great; we have reached the end of the road.
"We are immensely grateful to all of you who have supported us for the best part of a decade."
They added: "We sincerely wish the best to the new operator, and stand ready to work constructively with the Corporation, in a spirit of openness, to secure the best possible outcome for all those affected, including our beloved staff and colleagues."
Daisy Green owns a number of cafes across London in locations such as Regent Street, Soho, Victoria, Paddington and Richmond.