Premium Bond winners forced to hand back £518,000 after NS&I error
Premium Bond winners forced to return £518,000 after error

Thousands of Premium Bond holders have been told to return winnings after National Savings and Investments (NS&I) duplicated prize payments worth £518,000 following May's draw. The Treasury-backed bank said the payments went to around 3,500 Direct Saver accounts as a result of a technical error.

Many of the duplicate payments were automatically reversed from customer accounts, but NS&I is still trying to recover an outstanding £1,600 in overpaid prize money. One customer who had genuinely won £1,700 said the bank froze access to his accounts until a further £325 overpayment was returned, according to The Times.

NS&I apologises and cancels duplicate payments

An NS&I spokesperson said: "In May this year, due to a technical error, duplicate Premium Bonds prize payments were made to around 3,500 Direct Saver accounts." The spokesperson added: "We contacted all account holders and apologised for the inconvenience caused and cancelled the duplicate payments."

Despite a series of recent errors, Premium Bonds remain Britain's most popular savings product, held by around 22 million people. They work in a similar way to an easy access savings account, allowing holders to win tax-free prizes and avoid penalties for cashing in bonds.

Previous NS&I failings

The latest error follows a major scandal in March 2026 involving around £476 million in unclaimed or delayed funds belonging to roughly 37,500 bereaved families. An administrative and system failure meant that legacy products, savings, and Premium Bonds belonging to deceased customers were not properly identified or paid out to their estates.

NS&I management was alerted to the problems in December 2025, but the scandal became public in March 2026, sparking criticism that warning signs were ignored for several years. Chief executive Dax Harkins resigned in March 2026 and was replaced by Sir Jim Harra, the former boss of HM Revenue & Customs.

In June 2023, NS&I also paid the wrong rate of interest to 3,265 customers, sending them an extra £600 and losing £2m. At that time, those who were overpaid did not have to return the money. In August, a bereaved family was wrongly told they had inherited £30,000 of Premium Bonds. A male relative, who said he intended to use the money to pay for a loved one's funeral, complained to the Financial Ombudsman Service but was given just a few hundred pounds in compensation.

Compensation may be possible

Consumer rights expert Martyn James said that while customers were not entitled to keep payments made in error, they may be able to appeal to the bank for compensation. "If they told you you'd won it and given you the expectation the cash was yours, you could argue that you shouldn't have to give it back," he said. "While you may not get the lot, a suitable compensation payment may apply if you can demonstrate you entered into an agreement off the back of what the firm told you. So if you were told you'd won £3,000 and bought a three-piece sofa suite, you could say you wouldn't have done that had you not been told you'd won the money."