Alan Milburn has urged ministers to cut business taxes and ease regulations to encourage employers to hire more young people, a move that could clash with trade unions and the Labour left over employment rights. The former health secretary published his year-long review into youth unemployment on Wednesday, which Prime Minister Andy Burnham called a “watershed moment” for young people.
While ministers embraced his central recommendation to cut benefit and sickness payments to fund more employment support, his proposals on workers’ rights, national insurance, and the minimum wage pose awkward dilemmas for the government.
Key Recommendations
In the 278-page report, Milburn called for cutting national insurance for companies that hire young workers, applying a “cautionary principle” when abolishing exploitative zero-hours contracts, and slowing the rise in youth rates of the minimum wage. “A new bargain needs to be struck between employers and government: employers should create more first chances; government should make it easier and less risky for employers to do so,” he wrote. “That is the give and the get.”
Trade unions warned against some proposals, despite broadly welcoming Milburn’s push for a drastic expansion in state support for the almost 1 million young people not in education or work. Paul Nowak, general secretary of the Trades Union Congress, urged the government to “crack on and deliver its guaranteed hours rights in full” in the face of business lobbying.
Reaction and Funding
Burnham welcomed the report on Tuesday, telling cabinet colleagues it represented a “comprehensive vision” for changing welfare, health, and education systems for young people. He joined Pat McFadden in the Commons, where the work and pensions secretary told MPs the government would deliver “a new settlement for young people”.
Under Milburn’s plan, the government would spend nearly £2bn a year on a youth opportunity service, providing support and advice to give every young person a guaranteed route into education, training, or work. This includes just over £2bn for vocational training and apprenticeships, and £1bn in direct payments and tax breaks for companies hiring young people.
The system would be paid for largely by replacing young people’s disability and sickness benefits with a single youth allowance, which would be considerably less than some can currently claim. People aged 18-24 would no longer be able to claim personal independence payments, replaced by a new allowance for those with “well established, significant and ongoing” conditions. The benefit cuts would save £3.6bn by 2036-37, with an additional £2.4bn in higher tax receipts, almost entirely swallowed by the £5.8bn cost of the new system.
Political and Business Reactions
Ministers and Milburn have sought to avoid the backlash that met Keir Starmer’s attempts last year to cut the benefits bill by £5bn. Early signs suggest outreach has been successful, with several architects of last year’s rebellion speaking in favour. Debbie Abrahams, chair of the work and pensions select committee, called the review “an opportunity of a generation”, adding: “We must change the status quo.”
Burnham and McFadden expressed support for shifting money from benefits to employment support but did not explicitly back recommendations on national insurance or zero-hours contracts. McFadden told the Commons: “We know that employment costs matter and we will consider all these things as we move forward.”
Business leaders welcomed the recommendations, particularly the call to backtrack on Labour’s increase in employer national insurance with a tax cut for under-25s, starting in retail and hospitality. Maxine Bligh, interim chief executive of the Recruitment and Employment Confederation, said: “Tackling the Neet crisis gives ministers the perfect opportunity to reconsider a guaranteed hours gamble that risks costing jobs and damaging the chances of young people accessing the labour market.”
Industry chiefs have intensified lobbying against the Employment Rights Act, with a warm reception from Kemi Badenoch’s Conservatives. Andrew Griffith, the shadow chancellor, said Labour was pressing ahead with an “unemployment act” that would hit youth jobs. “You cannot solve a youth jobs emergency without jobs, and this government has spent two years destroying them.” Government analysis published this year showed estimated costs to employers could range from £350m to £2.9bn a year, with a central estimate of £1.1bn.
Unions and charities urged Burnham not to water down the plans. Joanne Thomas, general secretary of Usdaw, said “crucial policies” on workers’ rights needed to be retained. “We are clear that the government must ensure that employment is fairly paid and secure, with workers being treated with dignity and respect.” Clare McNeil, chief executive of the charity Timewise, said: “Where we disagree with Alan Milburn is in any suggestion that the new responsibilities in the Employment Rights Bill will stop employers hiring.”
Allies of housing secretary Angela Rayner insisted her proposals would not discourage hiring, though she is no longer in charge of the policy, which must now be implemented by business secretary Jonathan Reynolds.