The Association of Convenience Stores (ACS) has welcomed proposals in the Milburn Review to cut the cost of employing people under 25, including a reduction in employer National Insurance contributions for younger staff.
The review, titled “From a Welfare State to a Working State”, aims to address the growing number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEETs).
Key proposals to support youth employment
Among the recommendations are that the government should not increase the costs to employers of hiring young people further, and that it should publish a youth employment cost index every two years itemising the financial impact of its decisions on the youth labour market.
On the minimum wage, the review says the government should continue to direct the Low Pay Commission to judge the pace of convergence between the young person’s rate and the adult rate against the critical goal of protecting youth employment.
National Insurance and hiring incentives
For young retail and hospitality workers, the review proposes doubling the point at which employer National Insurance becomes payable for those young people, from the current £5,000 threshold to £10,000 within the next five years.
Employers who take on any young person who has not been in education, employment or training for six months would receive a £3,000 payment, extending eligibility to the 314,000 NEETs who are hidden and not in the benefit system. An extra premium payment of £2,000 would go to employers taking on somebody facing substantially greater barriers, such as care-leavers or disabled young people.
Retail sector concerns and reaction
The ACS and others have already raised concerns about the effect of changes to employer National Insurance contributions, which made it more expensive to hire people when the government lowered the employer NICs threshold from £9,100 to £5,000 in 2025.
Retailers have reported that rising employment costs have led to fewer staff hours, retailers taking on more hours themselves, and investment decisions being delayed or cancelled to make ends meet.
ACS chief executive Ed Woodall said: “Proposals to reduce employer national insurance costs when taking on young people will be welcomed by convenience retailers.
“Local shops provide secure, local, flexible jobs, but rising employment costs have made it difficult for retailers to take on new starters and offer more hours.
“If the government wants to increase opportunities for young people, it must also make it easier and more affordable for businesses to create those jobs.”
Ross Shuttleworth, delivery director for retail at apprenticeship provider Lifetime Training, also welcomed the review and encouraged the government to go further. He said: “Retail has long provided young people with an important first step into work.
“The ambition to significantly increase apprenticeship participation and completions is welcome, but delivering it will require employers to have the confidence to create opportunities and clear progression routes for people once they are in work.
“The report is right to consider reducing employer national insurance costs for 21- to 24-year-olds in retail and hospitality.
“It is also right that financial incentives should reward retention rather than simply recruitment. The aim cannot just be to get more young people through the door. It has to be to help them stay and succeed.
“But retention shouldn’t be the end of the ambition either. Young people need somewhere to progress.”