Milburn review: UK Neet numbers could hit 1.25 million by 2031
Milburn review: Neet numbers could hit 1.25 million by 2031

The long-awaited Milburn review into young people not in education, employment or training (Neets) has been published, warning that the UK's Neet population could rise to 1.25 million by 2031 without significant intervention.

The 278-page report, titled “From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation”, was commissioned exactly 12 months ago by Keir Starmer's government. It recommends a raft of policy changes across employment, welfare and education to reduce the number of Neets in the UK.

There are currently 981,000 people aged 16 to 24 in the UK considered Neets, costing around £125 billion a year. Milburn suggests that figure could rise to 1.25 million by 2031 if no action is taken.

Key findings and costs

The report finds that the UK has one of the highest Neet rates in Europe, with only Romania recording a higher proportion, while Denmark, Norway, Germany and The Netherlands record lower levels than the UK. Six in ten young Neets have never had a job, compared with four in ten in 2005.

The failure to address youth economic inactivity costs the country around £125 billion a year, including almost £22 billion in direct fiscal costs. Without significant intervention, the Neet rate could reach 16.3 per cent – about 1.27 million young people – by 2031.

Nearly 57,000 16 and 17-year-olds in England are Neet, despite a statutory expectation that none should be. The number of young people claiming disability benefits is expected to quadruple between 2012 and 2037, with conditions such as anxiety, depression, ADHD and autism driving much of the growth.

Proposed reforms

Among the review's suggestions is that the Government should dramatically cut the amount it spends on benefits for young people and redirect the money into employment, education and training. The Government currently spends around £25 on benefits for young people for every £1 it invests in helping them into employment. Mr Milburn says this should be reduced to £2 to £1.

“I know much of the public debate is about welfare reform. But this is far bigger than that,” says Mr Milburn. “It is about life chances for this generation and those that will follow. You cannot solve the Neet crisis by simply pulling a welfare lever. A whole system reset is needed.”

Despite the “sobering” picture, Mr Milburn says the report has “left me more optimistic than when I began” and given him a “sense of hope”. He insists that the young people he has met in the 12 months he has carried out the review do not want to be Neets.

“And it is this, above all else, that has made me feel optimistic,” he says. “This is not a generation that lacks resilience or ambition. The young people I have met want to make something of their lives. They want independence. They want to earn their own money. They want to be useful. They want someone to give them a chance. What too many of them lack is not effort. It is opportunity.”

Youth Allowance and employer incentives

Mr Milburn proposes introducing a single Youth Allowance, set at the standard rate of Universal Credit, for under-25s, with a higher rate for those living independently. The new system would remove the Universal Credit health top-up and the need for a Work Capability Assessment, which the report argues can make premature judgements about a young person's ability to work.

Young people would receive guaranteed support and opportunities to participate in learning or employment through a new Youth Opportunity Service (YOS). Employers would be offered financial incentives to recruit young people who have struggled to find work.

Under the proposals, businesses taking on someone who has been Neet for at least six months would receive £3,000, with an additional £2,000 for employing someone facing greater barriers, such as a care leaver or disabled young person. Smaller businesses with fewer than 50 employees would be eligible for a further £2,000 payment.

The package, estimated to cost around £1.1 billion a year once fully implemented, is intended to create an additional 170,000 job and apprenticeship opportunities. The report also proposes reducing employer National Insurance costs for younger workers in retail and hospitality, two sectors which account for 37 per cent of jobs held by 16 to 24-year-olds.

“Given the fiscal position, I do not believe an immediate across-the-board National Insurance cut is the best use of several billion pounds of public money,” says Milburn.

Devolution and local leadership

The report places significant emphasis on devolving responsibility for tackling youth unemployment away from Whitehall and towards regional mayors and local authorities. Greater Manchester could be among the areas given greater powers to keep young people in education, training or employment, building on existing initiatives in the city region.

The proposals come as Bev Craig has announced that she will appoint a new deputy mayor to tackle Greater Manchester's youth unemployment crisis. The move will form part of a wider push to give young people better routes from education into work, with the mayor calling on the government to hand Greater Manchester greater control over skills funding and apprenticeships. The new deputy mayor will also act as the city-region's skills commissioner.

Milburn argues that local leaders are better placed to understand the employment opportunities and challenges facing young people in their communities. He said: “I propose an immediate devolved mobilisation fund through existing devolution arrangements so strategic authorities and local authorities can expand outreach, case management and opportunity brokerage while full transfers are prepared.”

The report argues that mayors should take on expanded responsibilities for coordinating education, skills, employment and health services, with every area expected to establish a YOS. These services would provide young people with a single point of contact, helping them navigate opportunities and access the support they need to move into work or education.

Education and apprenticeships

Greater Manchester's existing Beeline initiative is highlighted as an example of how local areas can create clearer pathways between education and employment. Part of the Greater Manchester Baccalaureate (MBacc), Beeline aims to connect young people's educational choices with the skills and jobs available in the local economy. The initiative was developed under former mayor Andy Burnham's leadership, in response to what he described as England's “academic bias”.

Milburn wants to see that approach replicated across the country. He proposes that every strategic authority publish a clear pathway map showing how decisions made at 14, 16 and 18 connect to further study, apprenticeships and employment. The report says the success of vocational education should not simply be measured by the number of vocational GCSEs taken, but by whether pupils progress into higher-level study, apprenticeships or work.

The report's wider devolution proposals would see strategic authority mayors given greater responsibility for tackling the causes of youth unemployment, including health inequalities and access to education. It argues that responsibility for improving young people's prospects cannot sit with individual government departments working in isolation.

In a section on how the NHS could better support young people into work, Mr Milburn points to Greater Manchester and South Yorkshire as examples. Both areas have combined the roles of Integrated Care Board chair and Mayoral Health Commissioner, creating a position accountable to NHS leadership and the elected mayor.

Milburn writes: “Devolution cannot succeed if Whitehall remains fragmented while asking places to integrate. Government needs to join itself up before it can credibly require places to do the same.”

The report also proposes expanding opportunities for young people through apprenticeships and further education. It calls for an initial 25,000 pre-apprenticeship places, with a longer-term ambition of reaching 270,000 apprenticeship starts a year among under-25s by 2036. A further 150,000 18 to 24-year-olds should participate in further education each year over the next decade.

Milburn estimates that around 500,000 additional employment and education opportunities could be needed by 2036. He also wants the public sector to play a greater role, proposing that at least 11 per cent of the Civil Service's entry-level workforce should be aged 16 to 24 by 2032.

Schools and health

Schools are another key part of the proposed changes, with the report arguing that intervention must begin well before young people reach the point of becoming Neet. It calls for stronger connections between schools, colleges, employers and local authorities to ensure young people understand the opportunities available to them.

Greater powers will be given to Ofsted, the schools inspectorate, which will then determine whether students have been equipped with the right tools for the workplace. The report highlights the importance of work experience, with just 39 per cent of Neet respondents saying they had completed work experience at secondary school.

It also points to a significant gap between young people's ambitions and the opportunities available to them. Some 73 per cent of Neet respondents said they wanted to move into work, education or training, while 61 per cent of those wanting to move forward said they could start immediately if the right opportunity became available. More than half (53 per cent) of those wanting to work said a lack of experience was their biggest barrier, while 31 per cent cited a lack of the right skills.

Mental health and wider health problems are also identified as major drivers of economic inactivity. Almost half (48 per cent) of Neets reported having a long-term health condition, compared with 25 per cent of those who were not Neet.

Milburn argues that the health system is too focused on diagnosing and treating illness once it has developed, rather than identifying problems early and preventing them from escalating. The report calls for a greater focus on prevention and better integration between health, education and employment services. It argues that young people experiencing mental ill health should be supported before their difficulties lead to them dropping out of education or becoming detached from the jobs market.

Mr Milburn claims failing to act will mean the number of young people shut out of education and employment will continue to grow. “Our country is at a fork in the road,” he says. “Go on as we are and see the Neet crisis grow. Or change course and make the difficult changes that can shift the trajectory. This is a moment of choice for the country. Half measures will not do.”